When it comes to Iran, can women make the difference?
Supporters of defeated reformist presidential candidate Mir Hossein Mousavi demonstrate in Tehran. (PHOTO CREDIT: GETTY IMAGES)
FROM CNN's Jack Cafferty:
Ordinary women have been playing an extraordinary role in the events following Iran's disputed election.
The most powerful example - the 26-year-old woman named Neda, who seemed to be only observing a demonstration when she was gunned down in the streets of Tehran with a single bullet to the chest. A crudely shot video of her final moments has been all over the web... instantly making her a martyr.
Neda is a symbol for all women who have become involved in this movement - an image of both the brutality of the regime and the significant role women are playing in fighting it. And there are many more like Neda.
As the protests and clashes with military forces continue, we continue to see images of women on the streets; they wear their scarves and traditional clothing. Some chant, some march, some collect rocks for ammunition against security forces. Riot police have even been seen clubbing women dressed in black robes. Real macho stuff - beating women with clubs.
One 19-year-old woman tells CNN that she's not scared of the security forces - no matter how many times she gets beaten: "When they want to hit me, I say hit. I have been hit so many times and this time it doesn't matter. I just want to help my brothers and sisters." She says women have been out in the streets in larger numbers than men.
One analyst says in the 1979 revolution, the iconic images were those of "bearded men." This time it's young women who are "the vanguards of Iran."
Here’s my question to you: When it comes to Iran, can women ultimately make the difference?
Interested to know which ones made it on air?
Lindsay writes:
Yes, women absolutely can! I've heard that there are more women out protesting in the streets than men. It makes me happy as a woman to hear that they're taking a stand for what they believe in regardless of the misogynistic rules of the country they have been cursed to live in.
Jennifer from Winnipeg writes:
I wish they could make a difference. But the way women are seen and treated by the men in that part of the world, it doesn't look too promising. Neda was shot down and died in the street. Has anyone been charged with her murder? I doubt it, because she was very probably shot by their so-called law enforcement. Women have no rights or worth there and probably never will, I'm very sorry to say.
Sylvia from California writes:
My best friend, who is originally from Iran and has family there, says YES. She also tells me that she is hearing from friends and family back in Iran that the government of Iran has brought in Hamas and Hezbollah thugs to beat up the demonstrators because Persian men will not hit women.
Cindie from Key West, Florida writes:
Ultimately, yes! As history will record, they are making a difference: by being there, by protesting there, by defying the authorities, writing, texting, calling out their plight to the world. By being beaten there, by dying there, the women are getting their messages out, one way or the other. God bless them all.
Sharon from Chicago writes:
Absolutely! Ultimately, women have all the power, especially when physical strength differences are not at issue. Too often, we just do not understand exactly how much power we wield.
Elly from Texas writes:
Yes, Jack, they already have. It was what we call in Iran "Shir Zan" translating to lioness. I am so proud of my fellow Iranian women. Once the government killed children, the women will never sleep until there is justice. Thanks for your coverage, CNN. Without you, I wouldn’t know what is going on in Iran.
@jackcafferty on Twitter
I believe so. Neda is their Joan of Arc and they are finally realizing that they matter and that their voices should be heard.
Yes. There are more educated women than men in Iran these days.
The women of Iran have exhibited great courage in the protests so far. I am sure they will make the difference as they are an inspiration to their fellow Iranians and to all who seek freedom from injustice and oppression. They are shot and beaten with clubs but they still go forth out into the streets for their honorable cause.
Brownwood, Texas
I wish they could make a difference. But the way women are seen and treated by the men in that part of the world, i.e. chattles, it doesn't look too promising. Neda was shot down and died in the street. Has anyone been charged with her murder? I doubt it, because she was very probably shot by their own so-called law enforcement. Women have no rights or worth there and probably never will, I'm very sorry to say.
abingdon, md
i hope so, as we will see the same thing happen in the u.s. government (our) is pushing the citizern a little too far.
thats the fact jack?
My best friend who is originally from Iran and has family there says, YES..... She also tells me that she is hearing from friends and family back in Iran that the government of Iran has brought in Hamas and Hesbollah thougs to beat up the demonstrators because Persian men will not hit woman......
Women always make a difference Jack.
From what we have seen of Muslim Men's mentality, it is likely the women in Iran just justify their sexist attitudes. I really doubt they would let a woman make a difference. On the contrary, they are likely to suppress them further.
I think they can but it will be more difficult since Iran is not a democracy. It will take breaking down the partisianship – tough task – just look at how partisianship has prevented needed changed in this country.
Yes Jack , I do believe women can make a difference in Iran. It's been my belief that men usually pay attention to what their wives say. Similarly males and sons do pay attention to what their mothers say. All in all I hope and what like to see the women prevail and cause change in Iran. In another famous incidence they were the movers and shakers when it came to abolishion in this country as well. This is a clear case where we can definitely ID the real heros and give them the credit the're due.
I don't know if the women in Iran will make the difference, but with both the men and women in Iran speaking out and demonstrating their disagreement with the government, there eventually will be changes made in their country.
We did it in the early 70's and only after the 4 killings at Kent state here in the US by the military, our country woke up and we the people changed our country.
Yes they can and it is awful the way they are treated in the middle
east.
david
Women have always made a diffrence. They just haven't been given the credit.
Oregon
Yes, women are playing the crucial role in this recent upheaval in Iran. Women are comprising the greatest number of the population in the crowds of demonstrators so far, and are not afraid to be beaten, clubbed, or even shot by the security forces. Hopefully, a vast majority of Iranian men will continue to join the women protestors to swell their ranks, and hopefully the workers will announce strikes, which will take place very soon if not immediately in support of the Iranian people.
Yes Iranian women can make a difference for themselves and for their men. Right now the women are showing the most Courage as they demonstrate for their freedom. I pray God be with them.
if those women want change I say to them take off the muslim garments and tell the government god knows my heart. men are evil and controling them. if everyone of them take off the hijab and abay they will start a revolution which all islamic women need. double standards no longer work in this world!!!!!
Jack, it seems like they are making a difference. The final outcome of this is yet to be seen. It may become a revolutionary movement for women in all parts of the world.
Nuwan from Houston, TX
Yes, I believe they can.
It seems that the protesting has died down a bit, but I think it will re-group and women will be a vital part of it. Iranian women are educated, sophisticated, and politically savvy. Inshallah....they will make a difference.
In answer to your question, I will quote Malcolm X: "If you are in a country that is progressive, the woman is progressive. If you're in a country that reflects the consciousness toward the importance of education, it's because the woman is aware of the importance of education. But in every backward country you'll find the women are backward, and in every country where education is not stressed its because the women don't have education."
Pam Fradkin
The older I get, the more impressed I am with the strength and power of women. As a man, I'm relieved that women don't use it as often as they probably should.
I think this is truly awesome ..they are standing up for themselves and their people !! Way to go women !!
Iranian women already have made a difference. But no single person or group can do it alone. Mass support is needed against this corrupted government. They are bleeding, dieing, and getting arrested. They need assistance, not verbal support. Even I'm considering hopping on a plane to sift through Iran myself to assist the protesters and should it come to that, I won't be going alone.
Women have always been the driving force in most things, even if we men won't admit it. Just ask my wife.
If enough of them get out, I say: heck, yeah, they can make a difference. More power to them. They've been treated like slaves for too long, so they need to get out and take charge of their own lives.
I think that women certainly can make the difference. The days of staying silent and hidden while their rights are denied and exploited are over. The hundreds of thousands of Iranians, especially Iranian women, taking to the streets speaks volumes, and their battle cry of "enough is enough" is being heard. The world is watching and listening, and the persistence of these men and women suggests that–this time–they WILL be heard.
Washington D.C.
Jack,
Remember that when everyone goes home at night that the men involved in all of this come home to their wives and daughters. The Revolution isn't just happening in the street. The Revolution is in their homes as well. How would you explain to your wife why you spent a long day in the streets clubbing women?
We miss you in Des Moines, Jack
Women have been suppressed far too long in Iran. They will definitely influence today's modern Iranian populist viewpoints. The Iranian gov't has no idea or concept of the wrath a woman can inflict when angered by stupidity.
For every person who gets beaten especially women, a martyr is created. Those ignorant know-it-alls in charge don't realize the high level of resolve they have created in the power to be free. Once freedom is out of the box, there is no way it can get shoved, beaten or tortured back in.
I for believe the Women of Iran can lead the way for Freedom in that Nation. For too long they have been treated as dirt, it is their time, their time to light the way to freedom. And we the people of America need to do all that we can to help and support the Women and Men of Iran in their pursuit of Freedom.
And our President needs to give a stronger tone of support to the People of Iran, and denounce the cruel and heartless Regime beating and killing their own people.
They are making a difference already. May this continue.
Correction
They're fighting for the lives, rights & freedom Jack! These Iranian women wanf whats is right. Besides some of these Iranian women are hot!
Go for it Ladies of Iran!!
Women make up 60% of Iranian universities, they hold positions in every level of society. Women are the nurturers and teachers of tomorrow's youth. They are the molders of the clay that tomorrow will be a newly sculpted Iran.
i would like to know where the u.n security council is,where is the emergency meeting,these people are being murdered in cold blood, theiranian government cannot survive without other countries,get a backbone like the women of iran,stop these murderous tyrants
Yes, women absolutely can! I've heard that there are more women out protesting in the streets than men and that makes me happy as a woman to hear that they're taking a stand for what they believe in regardless of the misogynistic rules of the country they have been cursed to live in.
Since the women of Iran have been the most oppressed gender, they have more to fight for. They will probably continue fighting for the cause of justice and succeed at some point. It will not come overnight, but it's like Pandora's box has been opened and there is no going back.
Yes Jack, they already have. It was what we call in Iran "Shir Zan" translating to lioness. I am so proud of my fellow Iranian women. Once the government killed children, the women will never sleep until there is justice. Thanks for your coverage CNN without you, I wouldnt know what is going on in Iran.
There are fighting for the lives, rights & freedom Jack! These Iranian women wanf whats is right. Besides some of these Iranian women are hot!
Go for it Ladies of Iran!!
Of course...Behind every Man there is a great woman rolling her eyes Jack:)
Jack,
I am astonished by these malicious acts of violence against women in Iraq. As you say, "real macho stuff". I'm amazed at the valor and determination of these most incredible women.
Thank you.
Women are the single most powerful force on this earth. If ever you found yourself positioned to give thought for a moment to taking on a Mad Woman, I suspect you considered it a moment of insanity. A woman, from Iran, Briton, Canada USA or any other country is not one with whom any sane man wants to deal while she’s mad.
Never, never underestimate the power of women!!
Maybe, if their husbands will let them out of the house to do anything.
Yes, in great enough numbers, and maybe only over time. Men and women, young and old, should be working together to change things. Everyone in charge is of an older generation than the majority of the population, so change is inevitable. Smart leaders would know this and think before trying to crush any protests.
Short-term, the government may win, but memories are long and the population is young.
The women of Iran who are protesting are a HUGE inspiration to me. They are not just protesting the election results, they are disproving the stereotypes many of us in the US have associated with them. These women don't appear to be the downtrodden, second class citizens we have been lead to believe them to be. They are superwomen in my eyes.
We can only hope Jack, we can only hope.
Are you kidding Jack? Women always make the difference. Sometimes they let men think they are in charge but they know better.
Yes, if these brave women shame the men of Iran into standing up. Unfortunately, without guns or gases, women are sorely outmatched by men with weapons. Where are their men?
Yes, Jack of course women can make a difference in Iran.
Women have always been strong; I am a woman so I speak from personal experiences.
Beating women is wrong but it will make them stronger.
Iran Govt should be ashamed of themselves for the way they are treating women, men and children.
They are cowards
Jack, speaking from a woman's point of view. We make all the difference here in the US. So why wouldn't Iranian women make a difference there?
Jean
McLeansville, NC
NO! They can't even withold sex! Muslims run this show.
Those who have less to lose take more risks. Why wouldn't Iranian women, who's freedom is so much more limited, take more risk to speak out?
Absolutely! Ultimately, women have ALL the power, especially when physical strenght differences are not at issue. Too often, we just do not understand exactly how much power we wield.
Of course women can make a difference, look what a difference they made in the governorship of South Carolina.
The worst failing of this perversion of Islam is its putting women into a subordinate status. The best way of correcting this perversion is to insist on the equality of men and women as a matter of inalienable right.
Jim, Craig, CO
Ultimately, YES! As history will record...they ARE making a difference, by being there, by protesting there, by defying the authorities, writing, texting, calling out their plight to the world, by being beaten there, by dying there..the women are getting their messages out...one way or the other....god bless them all.
neda is the 21st century shot heard around the world
Absolutely! Not only do they have the most to gain from Reform but they are the Mothers to be of Iran's future Men!
No, they can't. When there unarmed being beaten, what kind of difference are they making? Just injuring themselves. The Iranian government doesn't care who they hurt; men,wowen, or even children. They government is just trying to keep everyone under the finger.
Jack, the only thing I can tell you is that women in that society were always oppressed, and that they can finally make a stand show what women mean in society.
Women always make all the difference. There is no such thing as an ordinary woman. We are all capable of changing the world as mothers, sisters, activists, students, and politicians. Iranian women are proving this every day.
Anyone here who thinks politics has any roleplay for the Iranian Regime is either blind or foolish. This is a dictatorship leading the way of martial law against the will of the people using individuals (mostly men) who do not want women to be at the forefront of change in their country. The Iranian men (Khamenei's side) do not want to lose the force of control that they have in their lives. They beat the women who stand up for themselves and speak out against the violence. Women saying to these basiji's " You want to hit me, hit me." And then he does it... What worth is that for a women to be beaten by a man? These individuals that are doing the beatings need to be beaten themselves. The government of Iran needs to be put out of commission, permanently. The Iranian women and men protesting against this regime need help!
Josue @Fort Hood, Tx
Jack, of course Iranian women can make a difference...no question about it! see the power of Neda's death that brought unity to the nation
I don't see why not. Woman and children were the answer in the Irish solution. Dennis , Ft Pierce Fl
Knowing quite a few women from the Middle East, Muslim and Christian alike, if the men allow it and ifthe women are determined, they can make this revolution work. They are young, know they have everyting to gain and little to lose adn are very intelligent, well educated people.
They will be the deciding factor if the men allow them to be equal. I do not think this is a question much anymore. The new generations in Iran, the last 30 years, they have seen the power of the women and no longer treat them as the unheard, unseen servants of yesterday.
Sooner or later women the world over will realize that they are the ONLY ones who will make a difference.
Clearly women can make the difference, they are tweeting the most, women are offering the most reports, and are being most defient.
anyone can make a difference, the only ammunition they need, is something to truely believe in.
It's women who will make the difference in the 21st century, women who will be and must be in the forefront, as they have tried to be ever since the 18th century Enlightenment. For more specifics about what is happening in Iran, I strongly recommend the book "Reading 'Lolita' in Tehran." I won't be around to see it, but the downtrodden - women, gays, minorities - will rise up and at least try to set the world aright.
–Norwalk, Conn.
Yes, we can. This will be a truly historic testament to whether or not chivalry is really dead.
Historically, women have played a major role in Iran's history, including the fight for women's rights in Islam. Shirin Ebadi, who won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2003 for her fight for women's rights in Iran, famously said "...By fighting for equal status, we are doing what god wants us to do." This is a struggle which will continue through the help of women and there is no way to deny their role in the changes which have already taken place in their country.
Last Correction
They’re fighting for the lives, rights & freedom Jack! These Iranian women want whats is right. Besides some of these Iranian women are hot!
Go for it Ladies of Iran!!
Jack, you should know this by now-women ALWAYS make the difference in every country! Laurel, Norman, OK
The women of Iran have already made a difference, Jack. The images of Neda's death are as the President said "Heartbreaking" I am struck by the serenity of Neda's other pictures that I have seen. She is the "Angel or Iraq'. Let her death signal the beginning of the end of the tyranny of the "Supreme Leader"
Absolutely, they can and will. Even though US govt should not interfere, people all over the world should unite to support this revolution.
Of course they can make a difference! They already have! The world is watching and they are watching the women of Iran take a stand. My question is where are the Iranian men? Why do they not stand up with the women? As I said, the world is watching.
YES THEY CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE. Women made a difference in countries all over the world. Iran should be no diffrent.
The Iran revolution will only be worth it if the women do not remain second-class citizens.
Women can make a difference but not "the" difference. Islam is a very patriarchal religion and patriarchs will be required to make a substantive difference.
I was happy to hear you ask this question Jack! 10 years ago I began praying on a regular basis that the women of the Middle East under the savage Sharia Law would rise up and defend their human rights. Today I am so impressed with these women and will continue to pray for their speedy success. They are my sisters and I love their beautiful contribution to global human rights. they definitely deserve our prayers.
Aloha from Maui,
andora noyes
The women in Iran are being more brave than the typical Iranian male. They deserve the highest recognition for what they are doing. The women are putting a tremendous fear into the illegitimate regime in Iran.
Yes Jack, they can make a difference. But consider the history, and the religious issues in this patriarchal society. It isn't going to happen anytime soon. On the other hand, we live in a high teck world. Anything is possible
Of course women can make a difference. Women are the ones who are suffering most, as a result of the oppressive leadership in Iran. So its only fitting that they come out in droves standing up for what they believe in. As a Muslim American woman, I am extremely moved to see these women doing what our religion has given them the right to do. Our Quran teaches us that oppression is worse than death. So, I'm honored and humbled to watch these sheroes fight for their lives.
Yes, they can make a difference. They seem so strong and determined. My heart goes out to them!
It is clear that the young women of Iran have had all they can take. This is a fight to the death. The supreme leader will prevail only over their dead bodies. For that reason, it is essential that the United Nations act quickly to get peacekeeping forces into Iran and demand that the government come to terms with the protesters.
Yes, women will eventually make a huge difference. In the short term the violence has driven people indoors but it has not changed their hearts. With quiet persistence and with time they will bring about a sea change to Iran. Women had far more freedoms under the old Shah and they thought that things would only get better after the revolution. Unfortunately, it got worse for women and it has taken another generation of well educated women to come out and insist on more freedoms for themselves and all Iranians. It may take time but the clock is ticking on the old regime.
Reminds me of the women from the Dune novels.
The Fishspeakers – a defense oriented army of women.
It may take them (especially the young ones) to through off the shackles of sexism. They may turn out to be examples for the rest of the world.
Jack - It's pretty clear the men haven't accomplished a damn thing so it time to let the women have a try. The Arab world has one hell of a time with their women folk anyway so this might just be the straw that broke the camels back. Here in Scottsdale, my wife gave me permission to send you this.
Gary H. Boyd, Scottsdale, Arizona
I think they HAVE made a difference, I mean look at the protest most are woman, standing up for what is right.
To ask can they??, is like we have not watched the news since there election.
The question should be, what can we do to help these woman and Iran to get away from there oh so Hitler like leaders.
I pray and hope they keep fighting for what is right and someone in Iran leads them in this fight for pure freedom.
These women will make a difference. Rather than our President who has chosen the path of a delayed response comprising of a slap on the wrist and an invite withdrawal, these women demonstrate the courage, the strength, the ability to put their life at risk in order to speak out against the brutality and oppression fed by a male dominated dictatorship. Viva Sarkozy and his statement against the burcha.
Yes, absolutely, women can and will make the difference in Iran to a more open and Rule of Law observant society. Gen. Douglas MacArthur included women's sufferage into Japan's new post WW II Constitution, and Japan has since become a model citizen of the world. Have faith in Iranian women, and women throughout the world, to make our world a better place for all of us.
My Wife and I have been watching your broadcast.
And, as to your question, I wanted to send you a comment my Wife Sandra made while watching.
She said; Those men can supress those women for a while, but...
they have to sleep sometime. And while they are sleeping, many wrongs can be made right, the table made level!!!!!!
Yikes Jack!...After some reflective thought, I think Women can level that playing field! I believe they really can make a difference.
Jon in Nashville
Yes, women can make the difference. I think that anywhere that people wants change badly enought that they are ready to die for it, they will get it.
Yes Yes Yes....My brave sisters are fighting for their livelyhood with iron fist. I have no tears left to shed for them anymore. I salute them from bottom of my broken heart..I wish i was there to help them and our country.....Freedom is near....fight on my sisters.
There is no doubt women can make a huge diffrence.Finally every mother in the muslum world will get their hearts desire.
Freedom.
Freedom from oppresive men.Freedom from restrive religious belifes that enslave .
Freedom to vote,hold office,judge,practice law.
Freedom to worship/
Women of Iran,take up the torch .The Democratic world chants with you,death to the oppresser.
Then live in peace...
YES, they can and they WILL.
Jack, what surprises me most about the overall election results reporting and the government's response to the demonstrations is that Iran acts and looks like a third world dictatorship. Their lies, violent reaction and murder of civilians are truly despicable.
As a man who knows a lot of Iranian women, I have to tell you that Iranian women have the bravest hearts in the world. After watching the protests in Iran ,I think almost everyone agrees with me. Mark my words Jack, they can and will make a difference
They are already making a difference and they can make more if we, as a country, through our elected leadership and covert operations support them. Unfortunately, we elected a community organizer, with no practical experience as our leader.
Iranian women have been the backbone and the strength of our culture for over 5000 years. Without the strength of the women in Iran this movement would be minimalized. No one is free till we are all free.
Ashkan
a Tehrani born, 36 year old, living in Los Angeles
Jack,
The old ways are beginning to crack in Iran. People are tired of their dictatorial theocracy and women are tired of being treated like disrespected pets. Women certainly can lead the way to reform, but it will take astonishing courage.
Jim
Reno, Nevada
Women were always told to stay in the kitchen and make food. So here is their chance to shine.
Jack they should have the rights they give birth to all people in the world so their voice should be heard
Amajenadad will not succeed if the women don't like him
theyre doing it now! mad props to all the women in Iran for standing up for what they believe in.....
They can, but I'm afraid it will be at a very high cost, unless more men support the same thing. The extreme side loves to be in power and it is exciting to them to be able to tell women they are worth 1/2 a man and should be covered or risk being raped/beaten/killed, condone honor killings, etc. Gives them a rush of power over 'weaker' people.
However, considering what they go through on a day-to-day basis, women have a higher threshold for pain and are willing to risk all for freedom, rather than live under the foot of radical Islam. That's why they want to keep women and girls out of school and away from anyone but their families.
Has is not been obvious at this point? I was hit so hard by Neda's death I wish I could fight along with the Iranians. I want to go out and protect these brave women. She has definitely amplified the urge to rebel more and I think as more women go out to protest so will the urge not to recognize their dictators. I will name my daughter after Neda.
Jack;
Jack;
The reason why Iranian women are making a "big" difference is because most of the men in their age group have died, in the war against Iraq.
The majoriity of citizens in Iran are 32 year olds. While the men were at war with Iraq, the women were attending college and advancing their intelligent thoughts. "The men, of the same age, were dying in the conflict(s).
Is it any wonder, why, the women are involved in this story?
Of course women can make a difference! Haven't they always, everywhere put the "civil" in civilization? This part of the world desparately needs estogen to mellow out the overabundance of testosterone. Untill women are elevated to equal status we will have constant war and beheadiings in the Mid. East.
Absolutely, women are taking a stand. How about dropping thousands of cell phones into the crowds? Might be a large advantage to have new phones. Thank you for your work!
Yes if they continue to demonstrate, but it will still some men who do not feel threatened by them to assist them. They can't do by themselves in that country. Clearly "The Supreme Leader" at this point finds little difficulty in having them injured or killed. We still need to see who within the power structure is willing to help the situation.
Not only will they make a difference in Iran, but for all oppressed Muslin women around the world. Like the US feminists of the 1970's, the momentum will only grow. Assuming the current tyrants are unable to halt this wave, the new Iran will be a very different place, especially for the women who made it happen. And when Iran, that vanguard of radical Islam, falls to the force of an angry woman, they will know what the bard meant when he wrote "Hell hath no fury ..."
Yes, Jack. IF changes to the system in Iran are to be made, women will be a driving force. Any fundamentalist regime that essentially enslaves women (or any group) does it because they are terrified of them. These men know that, if they allow women to be educated and have any power, that men will no longer be able to act like thugs and bullies. Women will demand that men behave in a somewhat civilized manner and these fanatics can't allow anyone to stop their cycle of violence and hatred.
yes , they can make a difference , the world needs to show more support , my friend is in iran we went to med school together and we saty in touch thru facebook , she's been going to the protests and sez they do it peacefully but the police comes and starts shooting....islam does'nt prevent women to be active and on the frontline....
YES! Women can influence one another, as well as their husbands and children.
I am reminded of Gandhi and his peaceful revolution in India, not one shot was fired.
Although Iranian women may be confined to the veil, do not underestimate their strength, vigor, and stubbornness. They are the ones leading this cause, because they are the ones that stand to gain the most from regime change. Their strength and defiance is shining through the veil and soon (God willing), they will be able to walk the streets of Iran without any restrictions.
Cut off all industries, and the government will fall apart! It's sad that old tired weak men who say that they believe in and love GOD, can only show strength by beating, silencing, and murdering young people! I think that all the women should leave that country with nothing but weak men in it! Lets see how long those cowards last then!
it's an islamic state, with that said women in the middle east don't stand a chance..men and religion rule that region with an iron fist lead by the biggest violaters of them our greatest alli Saudi Arabia...go figure!
There is an old saying in Nepal, a country that doesn't respect its women, cannot move forward. How true!
I would think so, women have the most to gain in this great opportunity to change their anti-female culture. They also have the most to lose. I hope they keep fighting becuase they will have to sacrifice many more lives to get any closer to equality!
Yes, From History, Does this not duplicate the Woman's Suffrage movement in America. Did they not get the results they were fighting for. The Nations of the world need to support this movement now.
Unfortunately, I think not!! The number of Women in the streets is encouraging, in hopes of putting an end to the oppression of Women, not only in Iran, but thoughout the Islamic World.
The Islamic Nations, and Islamic men will brutally crush any uprising by their women, rooted as their are in their repressive religious beliefs.
Jack, I am the oldest of 8 children. It feels like when we were all small and us sisters would watch our brothers get themselves into trouble and we could only watch for so long. Eventually, we would have to step in and help them unravel their mess. It's a sibling thing. OF COURSE SISTERS CAN MAKE A DIFFERENCE. I am extremely proud of the Iraninan women at this moment. You go girls!
San Antonio, Texas
Jack – I can't help but wonder if it was'nt for gun control in Iran would those brave souls still be throwing rocks? Or would this be over by now? Another fine lesson in what happens when the people have no way of defending themselves. Maybe we should send them more rocks.
I think they HAVE made a difference, I mean look at the protest most are woman, standing up for what is right.
To ask can they??, is like we have not watched the news since there election.
The question should be, what can we do to help these woman and Iran to get away from there oh so Hitler like leaders.
I pray and hope they keep fighting for what is right and someone in Iran leads them in this fight for pure freedom.
San Francisco Ca
Most of the violence and power stuggles in the world right now are by men in positions of power. The current violence in Iran is a reflection of the insanity power can bring to these men. It will take women standing up and saying enough is enough to bring sanity and peace back to that area and the rest of the world. It seems that anywhere women are considered second class (including here in the states), men resort to violence and oppression to get what they want. It's time for women to intervene.
No Jack I don't think that the ruling party in Iran cares for anything but power and control over it's people and in fact power over Islam as well! It will take the free world to take a military response not only to stop the beatings,killings and arrests of these true freedom fighters but also their support of terrorism and their quest of building nuclear bombs to control the whole Islamic people! NOW IS THE TIME TO SHOW THE POWER OF THE FREE WORLD!
Yes absolutely. Women have given birth to much that is "GOOD" in this world, progressive freedom being one of our "children." We should all pray for the women of Iran and that the military police realize rather than have allegiance to these disgustingly chauvenistic regimes, they should align themselves with their brave brothers and sisters who cry out for justice and freedom on the streets of many Iranian cities.
I hope so. I really hope so. I hope that they can lead Iran into a better, safer future, free of this religious (?) violence and manic response to the Iranian people simply wanting a recount. It seems horrible and evil now, but maybe they and their sacrifices can clear the way for Iran to be a better nation
As a convert to Islam and a Muslim man one of the things that repulses me is the mistreatment of women. I think it is great that women are taking their rightful place in their society. The religion requires men and women eqaulity and they should not be shut out of the goverment they bring the emotional side to life which we have been lacking for to long in the U.S. and the middle east. U.S. ARMY
Jack,
This shows like nothing else how afraid the mullah's are of women, they know the power they ultimately have and by keeping them covered and burquahed up, they make their fear manifest.
What a bunch of losers.
DaveO Cordova, Alaska
Yes, of course, any one participating in this venture will make a difference, the more numbers involved the more effective they're efforts will be. The fact that these courageous women want their freedom as much as the men should come as no surprise. I think most people, no matter gender, race,nationality or religion all aspire to freedom
All the women should leave that country, no one wants to live in a country without women!
It is the women who have the most to gain or the most to lose. I see "Women's sufferage "all over again and this is unfortunate. In the long run, it is the women who will definitley make the difference but not without more violence from their existing government. Who knows where this will end.
What a shame, what a shame.
Absolutely, they will. Their brave protests in the face of barbaric brutality at the hands of a government which no longer has credibility, are noticed throughout the world. But ultimately, they are raising the future of Iran, the leadership, and a generation which will no longer tolerate oppression and murder.
Absolutly, I think the weman of Iran have what it takes. Imean look at the impact of Neda. That's just one woman, just think if all the wemon had that kind of impact without loosing their lives. Men in that country should stand with the wemon and by doing so,n the regime has no chance.
Jack,
The women of Iran have showed amazing courage, bravery, and determination. They are going to need help from our administration and Hillary Clinton has been muzzled apparently. As much as our president does not want the U.S. invovled in becoming a scapegoat, it is time for all of us to stand up and make some noise for these people. Hopefully the women of Iran will get support from our voices here.
Herb G.
Bridgeport, Ct.
Women have to make strides in Iran because women are still oppressed in Middle Eastern states and the entire international system altogether.
Even though there is 16% total representation in the United States Congress, more has to be done.
Leslie
Akron, Ohio
I really hope they can make a differance,because with women running the world im sure it would be a much better world!!!!!!
Jack, woman have always had more power behind the scenes than most people will admit. Somehow it seems more repugnant to see women murdered in the streets than it does men and if this regime continues this practice, they will cut their own throats. Husbands do not take kindly to seeing their wives abused and murdered and will strike back until this regime is removed. It's gonna get much bloodier before it's over.
YES. The fact that men are beating unarmed women in the streets will, in itself, make an impact on the view the world has of this Islamic Dictatorship. The denial of women’s rights to participate in a non-violent peaceful protest will affect many country’s relations with Iran. President Obama said “The world is watching Iran”. This is also about the U.S. as “The world is closely watching the U.S. lack of support of human rights & democracy in Iran; as well as our nation is beginning to see the real substance of our president.”
Not a chance. The current regime is a Saddam Hussein type dictatorship. They don't care what the anybody thinks about them. It is a fact that talks and negotiations have not worked with the Iranian government or for all muslim countries for that matter. You mind as well negotiate with a brick wall. They will do anything to stay in power. The women cannot make a difference. I wish they could. Most Women and young children under 5 are the only muslims I sympathize with.
Women of Iran have more pent up anger than Iranian men due to the insane restrictions and lack of human rights they have been forced to live with for decades. Now that they know how real Islamic women live in other countries, thanks to the internet...no doubt they will be coming out in droves and are mad as hell and aren't going to take it anymore. Once you have a taste of freedom, you can never go back to repression.
As a North American man married to a woman born in Iran I can attest to the strength and resolve of many Persian women. From what I have experienced, few are willing to take a back seat to the demands of men who are hellbent on having their way.
Regardless of what happens as a result of this revolution, Persian women have already had a great impact on the state of Iran. And their influence in both Iran and the worldwide Perian community will only increase.
I only hope that the overthrow of the Ayatollah is swift and that those responsible for crimes against Persians are brought to justice.
Mike from Ontario
Of course they will ultimately make the difference. Contrary to the "common knowledge" of most men, it is women who have always made the difference–everywhere–and in the end their courage and determination will prevail over the prehistoric male monsters trying to control them in Iran.
And, by the way, I happen to be a man whose wife is not unlike these women fighting for freedom and justice on the streets of Iran. Over the many years of our marriage she has shown me the way without leading me by the nose.
Michael Downend
Scranton, Pennsylvania
Jack, Women will make the real difference in this mess. Women have always been stronger than men in such causes. Especially when they are treated as second class citizens. They have been the strength behind this movement. May God bless them for this! They are showing the world what thugs are doing in the name of a so called "Islamic Republic". The women have God & Allah on their side. The regime and it's enforcers better pray for their sorry asses when judgement is delivered by Allah. Free Iran & pray for the women ! Bob K.
Women are the ONLY ones who can ultimately make a difference. Just as women in this country fought for the right to vote, equal pay for equal work, and other forms of equality, it will depend upon our Iranian sisters to change their experiences and opportunities. More than half of the college educated in Iran are women, which makes them more informed and ultimately more powerful. Incidentally, the social and political changes made in response to women's protests have also made life better for men. I just pray that no more of these womwn have to suffer at the hands of the tyrants in power. It is hard road.
Women in Iran have tought all of us a lesson in courage, leadership and life.Some like Neda have given their life so that their brothers and sisters can live free.
I hope some day Iran will be free to elect a woman president, they deserve it.
Long Live Free Iran.
It is both extremely heart breaking and uplifting to see these women putting their lives on the line and fight for the country and the rights that they seek You just wish with all your heart that their bravery will be answered with what they seek and then some. My thoughts and prayers are with all these brave women and men.
Women in the US made a difference when it came to the spread of Christianity, when it came to their right to vote, and when they wanted equal pay for equal work. Iranian women can ban together and bring change for themselves and future generations to come...all it takes is for one to stand against an oppressive regime and from that one there will be the birth of a powerful movement that no MAN will be able to deny or stop. Go My Sisters!!!
Unfortunately, men in power are not likely to give away their power due to women's voices. It's not in their nature.
that's because iranian women have the most to lose in this election.
Yes, I pray they can. Though not a particularly religious person, I am
praying to 'whatever gods may be' for their success and safety.
Neda (may she rest in peace) was only 1 in a sea of green men and women who have bravely stood in the face of terrible repercussions from their own misguided countrymen. May their voices and peaceful demonstrations lead to true positive change in Iran without the need for international intervention. I am proud of brave Iranians for demanding their right to have their vote count and their freedom of speech.
Jack I'm 67 years old and was married to the most wonderful women in the world for 34 years.She showed me that the true strength of humanity lies within women.Women can and do make change happen. They just let us men think we are in charge and the movers and shakers. But its the women, thank God who are the real heroes.
The women in Iran will change it without doubt.
When it comes to women rights, Iran is one of the last muslim-majority countries we should be talking about. The question is not a fair one. It's biased and rife with propaganda.
Jack, simply put: women always were, always are, and always will be the difference.
As an Iranian woman I can tell you that women in Iran have a long history of influencing events and the repressive islamic regime only reinforced the sense of feminism in Iran through limiting their rights and freedom, insulting their sense of individuality and enacting policies which denies gender equality. People in Iran identify themselves first and foremost as Iranians than muslims. The women in Iran are strong, passionate and independent and fully able to influence the political events which we're observing today.
Yes, women have been suppressed much more than men these past thirty years, having their rights and freedoms taken away from them. It only seems fitting that they use this opportunity to take back what is rightfully theirs from this oppressive regime. And make no mistake, they will succeed!
Iranian women fighting government is not new and is not just young ones. It's been 30 years they fight the government preventing them to show their real Talebani face. The last four years has been worst for women, and that is why they are out more. I am proud of Iranian women.
Iranian women are the difference!! They are some of the most intelligent and most beautiful women of the world. They are unstoppable with that that combination. The primary reason that Iranian Men expend an inordinate amount of time trying to control them and keep them in the background is because they know that these women are head and shoulders above them in terms of intellect, leadership,wisdom, bravery, judgement with beauty to boot!!
Steve
Clifton, VA
Jack they should have the rights, they give birth to all people in the world so their voice should be heard
Amajenadad will not succeed if the women don't like him
Of course women can make a difference, at the risk of their own lives. That is not the issue, Iran or any other countries like Iran the uncivilized rulers have no heart for human being. There are many countries that have no respect for human right. That is not strange for some of us. However, what is very disturbing and disappointing is the roll of the United Nations. For how long they will be dormant? Such incidence needs serious thought and solution.
Well Jack I've been waiting for a global womens revolution for a long time now. I am suprised it might be starting with the most supressed of women. I thought the Catholic or Jewish women would be first to reject their second class status. Maybe they will take thier " i'm mad as hell and not going to take it any more" que and this could be the beggining of something really big.
Women have made all the difference in my life. I was raised by my Mother and Grandmother after the age of two. My Wife and Daughter bring such joy to my life. Can women make a difference in Iran? YES!! Women can and do make a difference everywhere! They can do anything they want!!
In a civilization that has traditionally treated women as second class citizens it will be difficult. But the courage and bravery these women have demonstrated to the world deserves a just reward and outcome. Men who beat and kill peaceful demonstrators, be they women or men, anywhere in this world are savages.... and deserve the same horrendous response in return. The women of Iran are turning the other cheek... their men might want to consider "an eye for an eye". On another note... Jack you are the ONLY reason I watch CNN. I consider your reporting to be the most honest and straight-forward anywhere on television. I tip my hat to you sir.
The women in Iran are making all the difference in spearheading change. Their strength, beauty, passion, and tenacity are traits that the Western world has not been unaware of. They are our beacon of hope and their actions are to be admired throughout the world. Let us all not ever forget what has happened and the role that Iranian women have played fighting against injustice.
Vanacouver, BC, Canada
-Amin
I hope they do but reality is that Mullahs are authoritarian rigid ideologues who won't give in to womens. Historically women are oppressed in Islam against its teaching for greater rights for women. Khamenei is no prophet rather he is radical Islamist who want to control the society under Iron fist.
So much for the revolution. Iran needs to throw these bums out. NOW.
The women of Iran, though marching proudly into modernity, are simply overpowered by a coalition of hardliners and zealots who refuse to allow any lines of thought other than their own. From falsely obtained "confessions", to the" terrorists" who are responsible death for the of Neda, they have proven their desire to rule with an iron fist. I wish the women well and will keep them in my thoughts.
Are you serious Jack? Women have always made a difference. They were some of the greatest leaders during slavery. Do the names Harriet Tubman, Sojourner Truth, and Sally Hemmings rang a bell? My mother was a single parent and raised 5 children on her own as well as my wife mother also. We are all successful thanks to these strong women though it was not by their choice doing it alone. When you look at your strengths Jack, are they of your mother or father? I bet most people will say their mothers. Iranian women has already made a difference, look at who is communicating information to us on their situation. Stay strong Ladies!!!
Absolutely, women can make a difference. They are the givers of life to all of us. Those of us who forget this will soon be reminded. As a matter of fact, it is already being shouted, all over the world. Especially in Iran!!!
I believe it will be the women of Iran who will change their country.
They should first start by throwing off the head scarfs (head coverings have nothing to do with religion...some man made this thing up);
next get rid of the black gowns....when they begin dressing as a woman of the 21st century, they will be treated as such....is this dangerous, I should think so in the Islamic country...unfortunately the men in Iran believe they are superior and we of course know that not to be true...women give birth, men cannot....I stand behind the women of Iran
Yes, we can.
The irony is that most of these women were born by the desire of the current brutal regime of Iran. This government in early days had encouraged families to produce more children in order to have more army available in future. This army of young people was supposed to help the brutal government during a potential conflict. To their surprise, these young women will be the ones who tumble this government once and for all, may be not this time but definitely next time.
Definitely. They have the most restrictions, and therefore will make the boldest statements. Although women are second class there, the few can always be defeated by the masses.
Women are the ONLY ones who can ultimately make a difference. Just as women in this country fought for the right to vote, equal pay for equal work, and other forms of equality, it will depend upon our Iranian sisters to change their experiences and opportunities. More than half of the college educated in Iran are women, which makes them more informed and ultimately more powerful. Incidentally, the social and political changes made in response to women's protests have made life better for menin the US as well. I just pray that no more of these women have to suffer at the hands of the tyrants in power.
Jack, I think it was a Pew poll that showed that one of the major differences between the West and the Middle East is that each believes that the other mistreats women. It's tragic that so much blood has been spillt over this, yet both sides claim to be protecting women from the other. That's why this particular conflict is so very threatening to the Iranian regime: how can they justify their conservative religious radicalism when the very women they claim to be protecting object to their extremism? So, the antidote to Islamic extremism is good old fashioned Feminism – who knew? It's a terrible thing to witness though – our young men and their young women dying for basic human rights.
I don't know about Iran but they sure can in this country ! Look what they've done to the G.O.P.
Bob
Louisvile, Ky.
Yes, women can make all the difference. Women are able to act upon their emotions, while most men simply act based on simple logic. Logic says, "don't go out and protest, you may get killed." But women realize that what happened to Neda can happen to any of them, whether or not they are protesting.
Iranian women have been actively involved and have participated fully in diverse religious, political, and social contexts since the eighteenth century, but frequently without recognition. The twentieth century, however, witnessed the destruction of most of Iranian women’s hopes and quests. Different Iranian governments enacted a series of important laws and regulations touching on “women’s issues” without allowing any input from women
In the last three decades, under the Islamic Republic, laws and regulations affecting the status of Iranian women came in the form of different religious decrees that were justified by the argument that they all complied with the Quran and the shariah. Iranian women have refused to abandon their quests for an equal status. You now see them on the streets and here their voice telling their story.
Minoo Derayeh, PhD
York University
Canada
Dear Jack: Women in Iran will influence the outcome of this election. The may have been hurt or killed but, they are becoming the force that ultimate will bring the political era of the Mullah marginalizing women authority.
Yes, after the 1979 revolution women in Iran have been taking part in many of the anti-government rallies and activities. knowing that the Iranian regime imposes Anti-Woman Ideologies in the country, women have been one of the main enemies to this regime. the main opposition group to the Iranian Government the PMOI is lead by a woman Maryam Rajavi and it is essential to mention that this group has lost many female supporters who stood up for their freedom and the freedom of their people. Long live women in this riot against this bloodthirsty regime.
Women can definitely make a difference but it will not be quick or clean. When more images of beaten, bloody, but still fighting women are shown to the world, slowly but surely things will turn. The so-called religious leaders will start to feel shame and humiliation for looking like barbarians to the world. Once those cracks start it will be hard for them to stem the tide of decency and modernity. But these women must reallize that their fight is long and dangerous, if they bend now, the fight back up will be even harder. It ironic that in such a male dominated society, it is the women that are the real warriors, but they have the most to lose so its now or never.
Women in Iran can no longer stand by and have their rights trampled. They also can no longer watch their children unjustly beaten, jailed and killed. We the Women out of Iran support them and will do everything in our power to help them. To be continued.......
Until the Iranian people votes count for more than just a symbolic gesture, their woman is even of smaller political concern.
as long as women of the world keep quiet, accept the male dominance theory, nothing will happen. Remember, the hand that rocks the cradle controls a countries destiny
r.landschoot pine city
I think they are the only people who can make a difference. The men all seem to be sheep-like in their devotion to their religion and will throw someone under the bus to save their own butts. Women there have been so repressed and undermined for too many years now, and I think they are finally showing some courage to stand up to the tyrants who have made their lives hell!
Jack, these Iranian women deserve our whole support and admiration in fighting a corrupt and evil regime. I hope they win! Why can't the UN or Western & other Nations do something to asist these women in there fight for human justice and rights. Surely there is something we can do to help. I appeal to all nations to DO SOMETHING for justice in this country.
I would say unequivocally no women cannot make much difference. The prejudice, gender inequities and injustices are so deeply rooted in this society that it would take the testicular fortitude of the Iranian men wedded with the incredible intrepedity of the Iranian women to bring about change. Simply put, Iran is highly a patriachial society.
Paul Albert
Spencer, North Carolina
Iranian women will bring change not only to Iran but the entire muslim world. True Muslims should be proud of them.
Yes, I believe that the Women will be the future leaders and Peacemakers of Iran and the Middle East. There is currently a void of leadership in Iran, and most of the Middle East for that matter. The passion, compassion, and tenacity of the Women of Iran is impressive. I hope that they overcome the repression.
The young women protesting on the streets of Iran are the daughters of the women who were told to go home after the revolution of 1979. These girls were raised by women who had grown up in a much more tolerant society in terms of the role of women. They made sure their daughters were educated despite having to accept many limitations. The daughters are now redressing the wrongs inflicted on their mothers.
Men might be the force behind a civilization, but women are its soul.
Some militaries train their soldiers to strike down women first in battles where both men and women are present. They say this is because a man may fight because it is a job, or because he's in battle to serve another purpose, such as power or influence. But when a woman steps up and joins the battle, she does it with an emotional connection to a cause. The old saying "the female of the species is always deadlier than the male" is true: they aren't fighting for influence or power or to reign over other men. They are fighting for their families and for themselves.
Can't get much more determined than that.
Oh yeah jack, a hell lot of a difference, these women have less rights the women had under the monarchy, the Islamic revolution was only a change for males, and it obvious that the government is scared of the women! Who are the ones getting shot? And beat? Women jack, Iranian women. If this does become a revolution women well are the ones gaining power and rights, I hope.
People forget that the engine of the Civil Rights Movement in America was largely driven by women and children. Their deliberate and courageous actions ultimately brought freedom and civil rights to thousands of African Americans, like me. Now it's happening in Iran. These women are sick and tired of being sick and tired. They are marching and dying for freedom in their country. That is why this lipstick revolution will ultimately prevail.
When you count as 1/3 of a man in the court of law and the opposite sex is allowed to beat you (but not in the face!)...the stakes of freedom and democracy are a lot higher than if you are the one counting 3 times more and doing the beating. It's only logical that women want a change more than man...they have the rotten end of the deal in these radical islamist countries. It's almost like slaves revolting against their master. I am 100% behind them and hope they succeed in their quest without too much suffering. If the world can help alleviate the growing pains of emancipation, we should do it. One thing no one has really discussed is how close all surrounding countries suffering from the same oppressive religion are looking at the events unfolding...You can bet all Saudis, Yemeni, Kuwaiti women are glued to some kind of free info channels and root for the Nada team with all their soul and prayers to Allah. Your giving voices to be heard is the best we can do so far. Thank you for people like you Mr. Cafferty. You give the Nada team the tools of hope and togertheness they so badly need. Even if I disagree with the archaic and dangerous views of Mc Cain, his quote is perfect for your actions You are on the right side of history.
Women in power always make a difference. In societies where women are empowered, children eat and testosterone-fueled aggression is reduced.
Hi Jack to see those beautiful Iranian women fighting not only for their respect their unsung hardwork and didication,the world could only be there to support them in solidarity,American Iranians and British Iranians and Canadian Iranians Franch Iranians and all other Iranians the world love you all.
Peace be unto all Muslims Americans have never been your enemy that is what your real enemies want you to think,over throw them all and come on into the company of the rest of the world where you have been missing your true god given rights.
The entire east must know the west is mixed with millions of easterners and you are our doctors lawyers shopkeepers friends and our neighbors,whatever they dau brings in Iran the Free world is in support of whatever your struggle demands.
God bless Iran you will overcome stick together
The women of the Middle East, in particualrly Iran is not understood by the west- because the only thing that westerners pay attention to and judge by is a womens head scarf......as you see today, a women is more than her outfit!
They are sofisticated, educated and brave- even with hijab. How many women ( or americans )in the U S stood up against Bush's elections that were fraud?
Of course women will ultimately make the difference. They will do so nonviolently. Gandhi said "If nonviolence is the law of our being, the future is with women." It will become impossible for Iranian authorities to justify or defend their actions against women who do nothing more than appear publicly in silent protest. Justice and freedom will come to Iran on the strong backs of Iranian women.
Yes They Can and i am extreemly proud of them.
Women got thier own way enven before they could vote. If they wanted a change in the old west. The man would sleep in the barn until he changed his mind.
So my answer you bet Jack
Bruce
Washington State
and yes women do make a difference and from what I hear 65% of people in university in Iran are women. One day they will run Iran, why not.
Women liberation has finally arrived in Iran. It will spread throughout the Arab world once women know that they can have a voice in the day to day affairs of their own nations. Education is their key to success and as they now have their foot in the door there is no turning back.
Seattle
Jack, I would like to say YES, women will make a difference as they have and do in most parts of the civilized world. However, the way women are looked at in Iran and other Muslim countries, simply as male property to be hidden and out of site except to be chattel to their "man", I doubt if they will be recognized at all, but merely beaten, tortured, and killed for their efforts.
The men who suppress women in Iran, and countries like it, have always known the power that these courageous women hold. Why else suppress them, but out of fear and ignorance. The courage I am seeing and hearing, from these women, is admirable and inspiring. Finally, the world is seeing, what women the world over, have known for a very long time. They are powerful, and people, everywhere, are listening. I only hope that their messages will be heard, and the ones who have dies, will not have done so in vain.
There is a word in Farsi for women who take a stand in difficult situation,"SHEERZAN" which means a woman who acts just like a lioness. These women are all lionesses on the streets and I am sure they will make a difference in their country, and in their children's lives. They are the ones who encourage men to take a stand and not back down.
That's where Iran will find its sanity.
Yes, but it might cause many deaths. The women are so much smarter than their leader, but are made to stay in the back ground and shut up. I would sufficate in those long garbs and my face covered in that hot weather. They need a change big time.
In the Muslim world, females have a 2nd class citizen status.
Back to Iran, the person with the real power is the Ayatola Kohmeni (check spelling please), do you expect him to show Iranians & the world that he is being forced to accept change due to females. Don't be naiive!
Why is the institutionalized oppression and disenfranchisement of women in Iran and elsewhere not vilified by "the west" as was the exact same treatment of black Africans by South Africa under apartheid. Neither our government nor anyone else thought we should "not interfere" with that nation's internal politics.
I am married to a political asylee from Iran whom has endured her share of beatings from the basij, for things like having her hair show too much or attending a private party that the basij broke up.
The events of the last 2 weeks have not been news for me, My wife has told me of the stories of brutality, and how fiercely the young people of Iran have battled back. The women have always fought in Iran, what is new is that now, thanks to technology, the video is getting out for the world to see. Now the world knows just how tough a Persian woman can be. How brave all of these Iranians are, old, young, man and of course, "The Persian Lions" the women.
No. Islamic men consider women of no particular importance, whatsoever.
Jack,
The religion of Iran will dictate whether women can ultimately make the difference One can look at our own country and see how religion gets in the way of doing the right thing.
Mr. Jack,
to be realistic, this ruthless uneducated theocracy will win the battle at the end and stay in power, however at least the word knows now that Iran "Persia" is not what is thought to be in the western world and that the government does not represent the country. at least the world sees the illegitimacy of that regime and knows that people of Iran are better than that and deserve better. for that i thank you and the media for shining the light in that dark regime and country!!
those beatings in the streets may break some legs and backs, but it will never break their will and spirits for quest for freedom.
may god continue to bless the free world and may god bless the freedom seekers in Iran.
Of course women can make a huge impact. Women in Iran will make progress in society. Remember, womens' rights in the US has only come about in the last century or so. The Equal Rights Amendment was passed in the early 1970's. Do we feel American women themselves effected this change? Yes. Have they had a significant impact? Yes. Iran will experience a similar series of events and it will not take a century.
Often we seem to forget about the oppression levied by Americans on Americans.
If the women can't make a difference they will emigrate and Iran will lose a valuable resource. However the U.S. and other Western countries will be blessed with educated and brave women if they can escape the thugs that now run Iran. Of course Neda was only "accidently" shot according to authoriies – they thought she was someone's sister they don't like and of course that makes everything OK.
When it comes to Iran, can women ultimately make the difference?
Unfortunately women have no status or power in Iranian society so the difference they can make in formulating policy is less than marginal...needless to say the future is grim and not likely to change under the present leadership, or for that matter under the leadership of any Islamic republic irreversibly mired in religious fundamentalism and religious otherworldliness...on the other hand why isn't the western news media trying to establish the identity of the individual or individuals responsible for murdering that poor girl in the lawless streets of Tehran?...seems a fair question if one contemplates the value of women and/or whether they make a difference in contemporary Iranian society...
of course they can jack woman are an untapped resource in the word and need to be heard and respected the fact that more woman are protesting in Iran speaks volumes.
What we are witnessing here, Jack, is the beginning of a VERY powerful storm. When you have oppression of ANY kind, all you need to do is offer people hope and then dash it. The Iranian regime CANNOT ever quell the fire they've ignited at the feet of their people. "Neda" may have merely been a match to the government. She is more than that to women around the world.
The majority of the population of Iran is comprised of men and women under 30. Young people are the new face of Iran, and women, who have more to lose under a restrictive state, have the potential to be the driving force behind this movement.
Women can make a difference in Iran , but , it will take longer. The men in power in Iran are not very nice and doesn't look at women with the respect as say , the men in the U.S. do. So called women's rights groups in America should look at what is happening in Iran and be thankful they live in America.
Absolutely! Look at the suffergette movement in the US and Europe.
sure jack, remember the civil rights movement ,how women like Rosa Parks made a difference.
It’s not surprising that younger more enlightened women in Iran or any Islamic state would want change. Considering that one of the fundamental purposes of their religion appears to be the subjugation and total control of women. The Islamic regime obviously fear women and are threatened by women rights.
Can women affect change in Iran – yes, but during their struggle they will suffer dearly at the hands of these hypocritical religious thugs.
John
Gander
The Iranian women will make a difference and will die if necessary to do so. The propaganda their government has fed them for years has been replaced by educated and intelligent minds.
No, no one is going to make a difference. If people would just stay off the streets no one would be hurt or killed, they are just asking for trouble. But again thats their life style. They don't do anything peacefully.
Never underestimate the power of women..
Jack,
While I commend the women in Iran for standing up against a tyrannical regime, the fact remains that the entire country is ruled by a religious zealot. In all actuality, it doesn't matter who is president in Iran; the Ayatollah is the leader of the country. Said religious zealot probably follows the portions of the Quran that claim women are but "half of a man." I hate to say it, but with that sort of ideology, women can protest all they want; sadly, that's all it will ever amount to. If Iranians want democracy for both men and women, the Ayatollah must go. Iran has an election for one reason: to uphold a democratic facade. One doesn't need x-ray vision to see through that!
Women ultimately make a difference. Period. End of discussion.
Barbara
Darien, CT
Everyone in Iran can make a difference, whether man or woman. The question is, who will capitulate first – the protestors or the government? I hope the Iranian people dig in their heels on this and refuse to back down.
Yes. They have been repressed since the beginning of time. Their emergence as a formidible force shows the Supreme Leader and the world that they are a force to be reconned with. It also shows that Iran is a unified society in this quest for freedom.
Jack the Iranians are Persians first and muslims second. Of course the women can have an impact so long as the men don't start killing them by the thousands. Even then what society can commit suicide by killing their women off?
I lived in Teheran, Iran before, during, and after the 1979 Islamic Revolution. There were many, "beared men" fighting, but there were also many women of various ages and economic levels who were in the front lines. After Ayatollah Komenei gained total control he rewarded the women by taking away freedoms they had under the shah. One of the first executed , a woman, her crime was directing eduacation for all boys AND girls
Yes, Iranian women can and will make a difference in their own lives and national affairs. New light has intered the dark recesses of the Islamic Fundamental religious constraints and a new level of freedom is moving through the hearts and minds throughout the Middle East.
Texas.
Jack:
Yes, I believe they can, but they MUST get far more open support from all the true democracies around the world. Neda's death, and the deaths of her compatriots, absolutely must not be in vain! The women in Iran's culture and the cultures of the other Islamic States witnin the region, have been surpressed for millenium, and I just believe it is their time, if only they can persist. Also, a hell of a lot more support from the men and clerics would go a long way in assisting them in their fight. Let us hope and pray they prevail, not for anybody's sake but their own. I salute the Iranian women in their cause, as I do all women who have had the courage to fight for their beliefs throughout time. May their courage be rewarded with freedom!
Gary,
Lexington,KY
In a country where woman are oppressed, second class citizens such as Iran? Absolutely! They are making that difference as we speak.
Andy
Nevada
I don't think women can make a difference in a country where the police can beat women on the streets for unislamic dress.
Women are making all the difference. The hardliners eventually will fail because no movement can succeed if you hold down half of the population. This is the beginning of the end of inequality and oppression in the wider Muslim world and we should be offering our support right now and for however long it takes, by organizing marches led by women here in the US and around the world. We need to let them see they are making a difference.
i am born in Iran,living since 32years outside of the country,loving my country and believe the only power to change this country and thrown the fundamentalist away is the power of women.
The women in Iran have paied mostly during the last 30 years and have never said yes to this fundamentalist, they have resisted and will resist,we stay beside them and help them,they are the future of Iran, and can save this country,
an iranian woman