FROM CNN's Jack Cafferty:
In case you needed it, here's yet another sign of just how bad the economy is:
Illegal aliens are leaving the United States and returning to Mexico in search of a better life.
You heard that right. One Mexican official tells the Sacramento Bee that Mexico has "become a middle class country" where it's now easier to buy homes on credit, get higher education and find a job."
Not so here in the U.S. where the employment picture remains grim. Just today came announcements from Cisco and Goldman Sachs that they're cutting thousands of jobs.
Plus - a report from payroll processor ADP shows that although the private sector added jobs in July, growth is below what's needed for a steady recovery.
Meanwhile - As we wait for the monthly jobs report Friday, consider this: Mexico's unemployment rate is 4.9%... compared to 9.2% in the U.S. You do the math.
It's estimated that about 300,000 illegal aliens have left California alone since 2008.
Experts say the weaker U.S. economy along with rising deportations and tougher border enforcement means fewer illegal aliens. But - there have also been significant improvements in Mexico's society.
Its economy is growing at 4-5% and, according to the UN, Mexico's average standard of living - which includes things like health, education and per capita income - is higher than in Russia, China and India.
Turns out Mexicans might just have better luck of achieving the American Dream south of the border.
Here’s my question to you: What does it say that illegal aliens are leaving the U.S. and returning to Mexico in search of a better life?
Interested to know which ones made it on air?
Can you imagine truckloads of middle class Americans sneaking into Mexico for a better life? It may be the only way to save the middle class of our nation.
Richard in Malvern, Pennsylvania:
Jack, it says that things are looking up! More jobs for Americans, fewer drugs and murders, and maybe this will have a positive effect on border states. Politicians won't do anything to protect our borders, so the slumping economy will do their job. How ironic.
Dave in Orlando:
It says that we are officially a 3rd world country. We have been driven into the ground by special interests, philandering, pandering, bribe-taking lawmakers, a do-nothing president good only at making speeches, and a top court populated largely by people intent on revoking the U.S. charter. Even illegal aliens are jumping ship.
Gerald on Facebook writes:
No work, no health care, no education, might as well go back. Now, where do the rest of us go?
George in Pennsylvania:
I just went to Sears to buy a Wet Vac. I found it was made in Mexico. Maybe they've got something there.
Ain't 'free trade' great? Waiter, another round of cat food! Any chance in the next election we'll get what we vote for?
Tim in Colorado:
It says that they are tired of the Situation Room.
Take me with you, amigos!
I bet if most Americans had someplace to go for " a better life", based on our economy and political system, we would be considered illegal immigrants.
Some are going to say that it shows how bad our economy is. I disagree. I think it shows how bad Mexicos economy is. Their economy is so bad that traditionally their surplus labor could find it's way here and it would all work out. Now, there are so many Mexicans fleeing Mexico that not even the US can absorb the volume so Mexicans are returning as there is nothing here for them.
Illegal aliens leaving USA? Fingers and toes crossed. Of course they wouldn't be here if our Immigration Laws were enforced and America were permitted the same autonomy as all other countries, save Israel
Something about rats and sinking ships comes to mind.
Jack to be very honest, I see ourselves ( american citizens) hopping the border for a job pretty soon if Washington continues on it's path to self distruction..... Just sayin
That makes perfect sense since jobs in this country moved to Mexico. Apparently the illegals didn't get the memo. Image Mexico having a problem with undocumented Americans looking for work and taking nationals jobs. And, American's don't speak Spanish.
It just may be they're leaving after realizing they may be forced to be legal human beings, pay taxes, contribute to this country, pay your way, be a TRUE American.
Heaven forbid !!
Can't we ship all the Tea Partiers over the Rio Grande and keep the Mexicans here? They can 'fix' it there and life will be better here.
Carol in Noho
I think it means that they have more sense than most Americans do. Job seekers need to be mobile, and those Americans trapped in over-priced homes are no longer mobile. How much time and effort did clueless politicians spend attempting to get more and more Americans in homes, only to find that they couldn't afford them? Or that they would no longer be mobile enough to pursue jobs? Another broken promise by American central planners.
Ron Paul in 2012...
Leave it to you, Jack, to find the one news story that demonstrates the US going down the tubes best of all. I say. good riddens to all immigrants finding "better" lives elsewhere including that arrogant billionaire who moved to China just recently
This should make both the left and right happy: obviously wealth is being redistributed and we're getting rid of all those illegals at the same time – there is a God!
They are leading the way for the rest of us. A form of reverse osmosis.
It means that they know where they stand in their own country (drug cartels, corrupt law enforcement and other problems notwithstanding), that their future in "the land of plenty" is uncertain and after all is said and done, there's no place like home. It also means that Sheriff Joe Arpaio will soon have more time on his hands than he'll know what to do with.
Jack i think you are confusing a vacation with going home to a better life. These people travel back and forth across the border like you or i go to the grocery store. The border is a minor inconvenience to them. Despite all the problems America has it is still 100 times better then Mexico. People get home sick once in a while Jack and that is all your seeing.
We should have followed the jobs. Our business people and politicians have seen to it that America's best days wont be coming. Maybe after a couple of centuries as a third rate Banana Republic we can reemerge, or at least attain the status of an England or France.
It says two things. First of all, many states have passed strict immigration laws since the Federal Government refused to do their duty and pass one themselves and some illegals are scared of arrest and deportation. Secondly, it says that the U.S. economy is in a sad state and there are fewer and fewer jobs. Neither of these situations are good since the supreme court will probably do what they do and overturn the state laws and the U.S. economy is not good for those of us who live here.
Gee ya think? I guess history will show that this administration was SO bad that illegals had to return home to poverty stricken Mexico rather than try to find work in the "Summer of Recovery" USA.
Good ridins to them, and don't do us anymore favors with their cheap labor.
it says that the politicians were smart not to wast time on a comprehensive immigration plan.
Mexico better start building a fence to keep Americans who want to reclaim their jobs from crossing the border.
here's a question for you is the sun setting on the American Empire, all the signs ae there, corruption, greed, lawlessness, a governmen that doesn't work,
It says we wasted a lot of money building that border fence.
Thanks, Jack! That's the ONLY good news to come from the Bush Recession of 2008!
Mexico is still devastatingly poor, and any commenter who spouts off that they're not coming over because we are in such sorry shape as a country, needs to have their heads examined. There is just no comparison in the US, where poor means you can't afford cable or designer tennis shoes, to large parts of Mexico where there is no food. I suspect it has more to do with the border states passing so many laws to let them know that they are not welcome.
I doubt it.
We hear those claims, but states are still passing illegal immigrant legislation, in all parts of this country, which clearly indicates the problem is still serious, it is still costing the states a ton of money, and the probability is........telling us that the illegals are leaving......is really a lie, to pacify the unrest over the problem.
Illegal immigration.......is just that.....illegal......but our government is doing nothing about it, and they are doing everything possible to stop the states from taking action.
That means, our government is failing to enforce our laws, and denying the states the right to make their own laws.
We used to throw politicians like that, out of office.
It says that ILLEGAL aliens believe in the same things that many LEGAL aliens in this Country believe in, and that is why many LEGAL aliens are returning to Europe.
I am planning on moving to Europe after I turn the LEGAL age of retirement, whenever that is going to be. We have botched up everything else in this Country, so we now have to wait until we are at the LEGAL age of retirement to see if we can retire LEGALLY.
I also heard that families in Mexico were sending money to their relatives here.
It tells me that they are a lot smarter than most of us have given them credit for. If it weren't so hot in Mexico, I might be right behind them.
it says the new laws in AZ,GA,AL and other states are starting to work. I hope so! That in itself will help the bring down the american debt.
I worked in Mexico for almost two years and just to get the visa I had to submit to a background check, a criminal record check and pass an AIDS test!
All we ask is for them to come through our front door!
In Mexico, you break one of their laws you go to jail or pay off someone to try and stay out. Here we give the free food, Housing, an Education and Bank of America gives them a credit card! Is this a great country or what??!
Jack, I'm all for immigration, just come in the front door like my grant grandfather did!
Thanks for pointing out the bright side of a lousy economy. It"s an ill wind that blows no good.
Speaking as an American who crossed the other border (Canadian) for a better life, I don't blame people for leaving. Ideology has turn the US into a country where nothing gets done. We have a government that since the 2010 election hasn't offered a single jobs bill, turned a routine debt deal into pure insanity, hasn't done anything to fix crumbling infrastructure or a crumbling middle class. Since I left life has been better and better, so I understand why people would do the same.
Jack: It means they are leaving the USA, because they love the violence of Northern Mexico. It really means they are afraid of being deported by states that have past new immigration laws, or it means they are moving to a more friendly states, who have common sense laws. It means they can go and come as they please, because the United States is going to layoff 3000 to 5000 border patrol personnel. Congress loves illegal immigrants.
It says that life in Mexico must seem worth the risk, as the U.S. is obviously going down the tubes and fast.
It means that if they can't get jobs or benefits here, they'll self-deport.
It means that laws like Alabama's and Arizona's are effective.
I don't think that's true, tghey are leaving because of hostility and uncertain economic prospects in the U.S. There are costs to live illegally or with uncertain prospects and Mexico is near enough that they likely feel more comfortable being poor with family around than face poverty here alone.
When the hiring starts again they will come back over. No houses being built by the thousands so why not go back home and rest and go the slower pace of life? Cost of living is probably much cheaper down there. Wonder if our workers can go down and make some money?
Scary scary scary Jack.
The best way to solve the problem of illegals sneaking in from third world nations is to make the U.S itself a third world nation. The Cheney-Bush team went a long way in accomplishing that; and, apparently, the Obama era has closed the deal.
tampa, fl they are still coming back once a month to pick up their social security checks and for the free health care. a glass can only hold so much water, and there are 5 people for every open job right now in america, so why not go where they not only speak the language and are citizens of, but ALL of our jobs went courtesy of our politicians.
This means that they have done what they came to do, which is, get just about everything for free, wave their Mexican flag, and send all the money they stole or worked for tax free, back to Mexico. Don't worry though, if and when our economy gets better, the illegal alien invaders will be back with the blessings of our silly, stupid and corrupt government. Don't go away mad, just go away, and stay gone!!
that more people need to go back where they are from and help thier people..not come here and take from the hardworking families who have to put up with illiterate drug dealers wanting to destroy innocents
Jack to be very honest, I see ourselves ( american citizens) hopping the border for a job pretty soon if Washington continues on it's path to self distruction..... Just sayin
That America is turning into a country like Mexico – the wealth held by a small percentage of the population and no middle class. The Republican Party should be ashamed and the Democratic Party also for not fighting hard enough.
Last time I checked there were over 15 million illegals running around in America and our government only recently came up with a really clever way to get rid of them - make the economy so bad they'll leave of their own volition. After all, America's on its way to third world status so why should they stick around.
Gary in Scottsdale, Arizona
It means that the states that are tired of supporting illegals is working and there are no more handouts. Hope they stay there.
It says that they were no different than a Gold Digging wife, and that is get into the relationship for what you can get out of it and then leave when the resources start to diminish...
that is the only way our gov will get rid of them i think obama has a agreement weith them to come back for election . some thing about a bonus
Well, it is not surprising since American Greetings, BellSouth,Coca-Cola,Evenflo,Goodrich,Kraft foods,PepsiCo,Rayovac,Samsonite and Xerox (and too many more to mention) all have factories in Mexico, it seems there would be jobs available there. Illegal immigration is a major source of the American wage being driven down to unlivable, and now it seems it is even too low for the Mexican worker. Perhaps we should be doing reverse immigration except for the fact that Mexico has a strong illegal immigration policy and it is enforced (just ask the Central Americans trying to come through).
It can't be too soon for me. The Manager hires them to clean the Laundry Room. If you leave and your door is unlocked they help themselves to your clothes, towels, washcloths and Heaven knows what else. They act as if the US is their country and we are the imposers. Good riddence to bad rubbish.
It means that its really gotten ugly out here.
Media hype is what it says, when NY looks like CA and most all non-corporate jobs are dominated by illegal labor, mostly Mexican. They didn’t all start out as low wage jobs but this country’s lust for cheap, slave labor has changed all that – with a helping hand from the Obama administration. The problem is so blatant and on such a large scale but we never hear a mention of it in the media. Why believe what they say now? You cannot have it both ways. You cannot be pro illegal immigration and serious about putting America back to work. In response to my concerns in a letter to my congress Rep. Yvette Clark – she’s opposed to passing partisan agendas. I call it unemployment!
It shows that we are in much more desperate times than some would like to admit. With a failing economy, a timid President and "children" "running" our countries infrastructure, I wonder when more AMERICANS are going to be running to Canada; not just to escape the idiocy but the heat as well!!! Its long overdue for some change.
Good now we can get on with fixing our life without having to pay for them.
My comment will be probably be the same as most commentators. This fact suggests that the good old USA is no longer the land of plenty.The unemployed citizens much remain and suffer.Now is a good time to reform laws to prevent their return when the good times return. First step should be to eliminate the destructive influence of the Teabaggers policies.
Aside from the obvious "shame on us" state of affairs which would cause economic conditions in Mexico to be better than in the USofA, I would venture an opinion: good news.
If this question is a bash on our economics, it is unnecessary. We are already too aware of the results of reaganism and bushisml.
If this question is a bash on our immigration policy, it is unnessary. We are already too aware of th results of reaganism and bushism.
Why DO you ask such an obviously editorialised question anyhow?
It shows us that in a little over a year the tea party, with help of some republicans has us circling the drain. If this continues it won’t just be the undocumented leaving. I’d trade the “job creators” for the hard working undocumented people any time…
Illegal immigrants have finally figured out that the U.S doesn't want them here...and thus now they can commit suicide or get shot back at home.
Surprised! Heck, no. After watching the most recent antics of our elected 3-ring circus performers, I'm not surprised. I say we vote them all out in 2012 and start over.
The end of the world is near and America is no longer worth the weight in golden dreams
If ever there was an indication of how bad the jobs market is....
Sad. Really, just sad. Immigration...illegal or legal has reached its end because of intolerance.
gotta go where the jobs are, Jack.
I'm working on my "Si, habla Espanol". maybe I can get "empleo como conductor" (work as a driver) IF the Republicans steal my Social Security and Medicare.
Speedy Gonazalez needs to make a comeback?
Simply put......our Immigration policies are working brilliantly.....Not!! Every movie I've seen w/a sinking ship in it. The rats are the first to escape. Looks like our ship is sinking!!! Where are the jobs, "Speaker", Boehner?? "His Helper" Kantor? 'No clue what you do", McConnell? Where are the jobs you promised us??
Well, since all those corporations that really, REALLY need their tax loopholes and subsidies to create jobs, at least according to the GOP/Tea Party, are really doing just that. The problem for us American's is that all those jobs being created are in Mexico, India, China, etc., etc., etc.
They are? Then someone needs to tell the ones here in Alexandria, Virginia to get packing seeing no one will enforce the immigrations laws in this country.
I think it means that the Mexican people now know that America is not the golden parachute they wanted to have. Maybe the Mexicans that are going back can overhaul the corruption going on in their country. Women in Juarez get slaughtered every day. Hopefully they can make a difference.
Pasar por alto que, mamar pollas.
Jack: Repeat actions are a clear indicator of customer satisfaction.
It is said that you never leave a sinking ship until it leaves you. That said, we need to be fixing our ship, because just like the Titanic, first class will get the life boats and the rest of us will be shark food.
It says one of two things 1) Enough American companies have set up shop in Mexico so it is possible for illegals to make a life at home and not have to worry about whatever agency is looking for them. or 2) The American dream is being found out to be the American nightmare and that it's just not worth the hassle to stay there illegally.
This is a true testimony as to how bad the economy is really getting.
In a way, these guys are really lucky; at least they have a place to go. Most of the poor US citizens and other folks in the unemployment line have nowhere to go and can’t find a good or even poor job here in the land of milk and honey.
The average citizen is stuck in limbo listening to the politicians in DC explain how each new farcical idea they generate will solve all the problems.
In the past few months, only one comment from DC has been correct
“All the shovel ready jobs weren’t really ready!!!!”
I'm glad to see that some people at least have a choice. Things are getting bad when illegal aliens leave for a better life. Now all we need is some of these idiots in Washington to leave. With the tea party coming to power we are now left with a nation of rich and poor just like Mexico.
They're leaving? I had thought the rate had slowed down! If they're leaving, then it is because of the US economy. I guess its' easier to be homeless at home than it is in the US.
Hurray!! Maybe, with any luck, all illegal aliens will leave
this country. That would save a great many dollars just feeding them and providing welfare checks to them. Follow Minnesota's rule, four years and off the welfare list.
Its pretty obvious Jack. This country is failing its people. America was the place to go to fulfill one's dreams. Looks like China and India continue to take over that dream. More and more companies are closing here in the States and moving overseas. Really very tragic for America. Those dreams have become nightmares.
West Chester Pa
It's gotten harder to tell which government is more dysfunctional. I guess they figured that they might as well deal with the one that speaks their language. Mida mida!! Americanos los locos.
They are tired of the low pay, ethnic intolerance and public harassment, but don't worry, we'll be begging them to come back when apples cost $5.00 a piece at the grocery store and vegetables are sold by the slice on the black market.
Jack, Glad to see the illegals return because theres no jobs here for them. If the economy gets any worse we will all be following them back to Mexico for a job also. Hows your Spanish Jack?
Terence , NJ
When our own economy is slumping and our unemployment rate is high, this puts pressure on industries that have been hiring illegal aliens.
The jobs "nobody wants" are now being sought. For those illegal aliens that have to go back to Mexico, I wish them well. Looking on the bright side, those who were taking advantage of the illegal aliens will now have to pay at least minimum wage to their workers and contribute to our entitlement programs.
It says the boat is sinking and the rats are leaving. The water is rising but I guess everyone is waiting for it to reach their lower lip before they mention it to somebody.
What a scary thought!
It says to me that I'd better learn rudimentary Spanish and how to do landscaping.
Why not? Mexico is still a developing country whereas the US is starting to look like a "Has Been."
One can but hope. Some good comes from every bad thing.
METALWORKER in IL
take me with you, amigos!
Jack, your comment is awaiting modifications.
Well I wouldn't call it a better life Jack. It is only time when our and the remaining "good" Mexican Army work together to clean up not only the border mess but the drug an human traficing mess that is going on now daily. Many Mexicans I know are moving here to the U.S to be safe and not back to Mexico. The better life are in the eyes of the beholder. The Mexicans with education and a good deal of money are moving to Texas for one. As for our boarder inforcement is a joke picking up the bus boy or the yard workers and send them back when we seem to not to be able to catch the drug and sex slave lords. It is just plane sad and good Mexicans are getting a bad wrap.
There isn't a silver bullet? The grass looks greener over there? There's no place like home? There's no money in this deal? (George Jones). Look Homeward Angel. (Johnny Ray).
They're no longer breaking the law. Enough said.
I just went to Sears to buy a Wet Vac. I found it was made in Mexico. Maybe they've got something there.
Jack: They could be leaving due to stricter laws (Sb1070), and not due to economy. Either way this is good news!
It tells me that jobs here are scarce here and that there has been a crackdown on hiring illegals with fines for those doing so. Also, "the better life in Mexico" no doubt has to include being with family and friends instead of living in crammed Third World immigrant housing here.
Well we couldn't stop them from crossing the Rio Grande south to north. I guess we can't stop them crossing from north to south. Hasta la vista!
They heard about fast and furious and are heading home to where the freebies are going. Got to get their Obama guns.
well jack ,it looks like children of the corn.now that the kids got what they want, what will they do with it?
Brian from Chicago
You could conclude that some folk are happier living where they grew up. A young lady that works for me came to the states, with her parents, from Poland 8 years ago. She loves it here but her parents never got use to the change. So they went back They told her that America has a lot to offer but it's simply – not home.
it means that the empire is falling apart just like the roman empire. the enemy from with in is winning.
it could mean one of several things: First, gasoline prices are much too high north of the Rio Grande; or they finally discovered that Taco Bell is not really Mexican food.
It says that they have been watching the news lately and have decided that life in Mexico is a better bet than the U.S. after watching our honorable Washington politicians at work.
Outside that it signals that the U.S. is becoming less dominate economically to the rest of the world, it also means the 'job creators' will have job openings coming up for nannies, harvesters and Taco Bell positions. If any American will take them, that is.
It will increase.
The quality of life in America is deteriorating for more Americans.
A term "kicking the can down the road" kept popping up in the debt ceiling debates.
This is not the only "can" that I see being kicked down the road. There are so very many cans being kicked that I cannot count all of them.
This is not the proper way to deal with problems and is why the numbers swimming south across the Rio Grande are going to increase. Many of these problems were being postponed when I was in college.
What an indictment of the action of our federal government!
I thought it was too late for this government when I was in college. I desperately hope I am still incorrect!
It's about time!
Jack, it means even the jobs that comedians like George Lopez says Americans aren't willing to work such as house hold cleaning and landscaping are employment opportunities Americans are willing to gladly accept. Working simply to send money back home to Mexico isn't as profitable when the U.S. Dollar continues to diminish in value.
It says "Thank God!" and good riddance!
Sounds like a good idea. I'll start packing now. hasta la vista baby
America has been the life blood for these Illegals for years. The realilty is Mexico unemployment rate is about 4% were the US rate is 9 +, and I mean +. More power to them to leave to seek a better life in their country.. Now what do we do with the other 12 Million illegals still here.. Considering our weak enconomy, maybe these folks will get the message and LEAVE.. This is a fear the Democrats Leadership is afraid of, they need their votes to give Obama a chance in 2012. the Liberal Democrats want to change US laws to accomidate illegals in sanctuary cities, provide State and Gov funding to support illegals still here in the US. Like the US has enough to support this madness. Our own US Gov sueing states who pass laws against illegals..
the Last time I look, The US is suppose to be a nation of LAWs not a propiertor for illegals to have more legal rights then US Citizens.
Time for them to leave or get to the back of the line legally..
Says that this heat wave burned up the crops and jobs, man that Tea Party must have some influence to create a change in the weather, LOL.
Or was it Pastor Perry from his bully pulpit saying some pretty mean prayers, and no laughing at that one Jack.
Simple, and the same will be true with India and China, this is where the American manufacturing jobs have gone. Hence, this is where the middle class will start to grow. Isn't this what corporations have been striving for for decades, new middle classes to purge, and they are doing a fine job of building these middle classes in other countries? America's middle class is about dried up.
We had a shift in the Reagan years where we began to base our economy on consumerism because of the policies he enacted that lopsidedly benefited corporations, well eventually when the jobs are gone somewhere else there are no longer middle class jobs here thus no money to consume anything.
Unions have been fighting this for many many years, yet haven't got the PR experts the corporations do.
It tells me that the only way to solve the illegal immigration problem is to make the U.S's economy worse then any other country. To any foreigner who is reading this -including me-, we can't help but get the giggles at the fact that americans have been whining on aliens entering they're country illegally. But now that your economy is in the toilet, you may have inadvertandly found the holy grail answer to the illegal alien issue, one that makes the phrase "the cure is worse then the problem" come true.
It says that we are officially a 3rd world country. We have been driven into the ground by special interests, philandering, pandering, bribe taking lawmakers, a do nothing president good only at making speeches, and a top court populated largely by people intent on revoking the U.S. charter. Even illegal aliens are jumping ship preferring not to take advantage of the freebies they can get for the asking. What’s a plane ticket to Mexico go for these days?
It means that we dont have the jobs here........something our media doesnt seem to be interested in is........Just how much money our econmy has lost due to floods........tornadoes........fire......and drought for Gods sake......the heartland and the South is burning up.......Just how much is it costing our economy?
It says the U.S. needs more jobs so people can make more money to buy more things to create more jobs so more people can make more money to buy more things, etc. The government cannot create jobs. It's the manufacturing sector that needs to create jobs. We cannot be a country with nothing but service industries. The way to create more manufacturing jobs here is to stop importing goods that are manufactured overseas not only by foreign countries but by American companies who have moved their manufacturing out of this country in search of cheaper labor and higher profits.
When they came here, they thought Washington had the advantage over Mexico City. Now they are going back home. Considering the obvious, if we were smart, we’d join them, but again, if we were smart we wouldn’t have elected some of the representatives we have. Did the corrupt Mexican politicians immigrate, change their names and got elected to Congress? Sure looks like it.
Did you mean Americans leaving for a better life?
jack its been a bad month out there job hunting sitting at home depressed untill now thanks for brighting up my day at last some good news their in the unemployment line to
Well it's about time. After putting a strain on our economy they finally leave. Good news maybe we can cut the budget for boder patrol.
Jack, it says that things are looking up! More jobs for Americans, fewer drugs and murders, and maybe this will have a positive effect on border states. Politicians won't do anything to protect our borders, so the slumping economy will do their job; how ironic.
It means they might need border enforcement to keep out unemployed Americans who try to follow them.
I say great! Never did understand the concept of "illegal" aliens having a right to free education, medical care, and whatever else they can con the U.S. out of with their phony IDs. What part of "illegal" don't we understand! If a U.S. citizen commits fraud he/she is subject to criminal prosecution, loss of job, life ruined, jail time etc. (Are you listening Bernie). We, in our infinite wisdom, want to put the "illegals" on the fast tract to citizenship as a reward for being here "illegally" for all those faithful years. Somehow they get the benefit of cutting in line in front of those seeking citizenship thru legal means. Let Sarah Palin and the Donald lead all the illegal aliens back to Mexico to show their leadership skills. Then they can both come back and throw their hats in the ring together as running mates! In the meantime Obama and his Democratic Posse can unionize all the jobs the "illegals" held and our unemployment problem will be solved! Who says we can't work together.
Tom fm N.C.
Understandable. Who wants to stay in a country that has no jobs. They were making money hand over fist doing jobs many Americans felt were beneath them to do. They were actually smarter than we gave them credit for. USA is heading to be a third world country and stone broke. With businesses stock piling cash money, the rich not paying taxes, FAA not paying taxes, Congress with their heads in their butts Look Out Mexico Here We Come. LOL
From Richmond, Virginia
I'm not 'certain' where your "info" is coming from but there are a few simple facts you should be aware of:
Illegal aliens are certainly not tracked coming in and neither is our law on such administered. So I doubt they're being counted leaving, if they are why aren't they arrested for being here in the 1st place?
"@" least interrogated and held temporarily until it is determined their not guilty of any crimes while they were here, and that they didn't have any kids that are now citizens.
If it's better for them in Mexico maybe it'd be better for "US" too!
If an enemy chose to attack the USA economically, how would they do it? The Tea Party just attacked America, and won.
Jack, it means that the years of work without paying any taxes is over. There is no money left in the piggy bank to pay them. Maybe many are leaving because now that the debt ceiling debackle is over, Congress may actually do some work and address the issue of illegal imigration. wouldn't that be an earth shattering? congress actually doing some work?
The "American Dream" is turning into the "American Scream" what with jobs, housing, student loans, the wealthy and rich corporations not paying their fair share of taxes, the debt debacle. Tell me Jack – Are those "R" guys in Washington Americans?? Sad!
LOL............if Bush was given a third term we might have gotten rid of our immigration problem already. As long as the GOP are caved to on important issues Mexico will soon have an immigration problem. We will be moving over there and the GOP won't even care as long as the big wigs and the corporations they run get all their breaks on the back of the middle class. Pathetic that the most powerful electorate in the world are so ignorant of the issues.
Ain't 'free trade' great? Waiter! another round of cat food!
Any chance in the next election we'll get what we vote for?
Costa Rico is looking pretty good to me right now after watching our Congress at work, not for the citizens, but for their benefactors.
BTW, I'm a native born American with direct roots back to the Mayflower and the Revolutionary War
I'm suprised you left out all the so called American Corporations who built factories in Mexico when Bubba Clinton signed Bush 41 NAFTA Act. We send jobs to Mexico and they send drugs and vermin back in Free Trade
I am so tired of being asked what I think about the US economy. Does it really matter what any of us citizens think? Do we really have any power to change this? Don't say we need to vote in new leadership....because the only thing we get are new faces. Don't tell us to write our congressman because they do what they please and what their cronies are doing. Unless every person in this country changes their mind and heart, nothing here or in the world will change. Wouldn't it be grand to start caring about each other and being the model for the rest of the world. Instaed of handing out money to other countries we can show them how a government for the people and by the people really works. What's your solution Jack?
It brings to mind the old saying, "rats flee a sinking ship." I am not calling the illegal aliens rats but this ship is sinking. (Titanic fast). Rob in NC
Jack, It looks like that's the only way we can get rid of them since the Feds won't enforce our laws and in fact fight them.
Better life, because egotistical leaders and CEO's are not interested in the "community;" their only interest is in the self.
If I understood correctly, only the small, and I mean less than 200 employees, small companies are hiring, because large companies control our agenda driven politicians and have no interest in helping America remain strong. For example, just look at recent news of GE and other companies moving production overseas.
If our self-absorbed leaders in Congress would realize we will not have an America to believe-in, unless they quickly place a mandate that all production must be within our borders.
Joe, Binghamton, NY
LOL...Whoa! we better be carefully about that border wall the Republicans want...may be to fence us in. And not to keep Mexicans(illegal aliens) out. After all who's going to pick all that cotton down south, after they all go back home to build that American Dream. I guess when that U.S.stock market crashes they'll all need jobs. I wonder how are grandchildren will be treated when they cross over the border looking for work. Will they call them illegal aliens or Yankee's with a slur. I once read in a book the saying "what you sow you shall reap"...What'ya you think ,Jack. Will we one day regret our don't come through are door policy.
A Republican crossover "Obama 2012
It says what we've known for a while now, our jobs are going to Mexico as well as China and India. Oh dear, what new group will the bigots now target?
Well I guess the watering hole has dried up and the free lunches ran out. IThe question say's we should, as a nation, be ashamed of our leaders for mismanaging this country. Next thing you know we will see an exodus of Americans fleeing to Canada.
This country is sinking fast and our elected officials don't seem to care. Obama went back on the campaign trail saying something about the economy and jobs – he's been saying that for 3 years now. The congress went on break, because their getting paid no what happens to the rest of us. Canada won't let us in their country, so it looks like we are all headed to Mexico. Rob in NC
ps. Make sure your kids take Spanish or Chinese in school.
They have jobs we used to have & if the Feds try real hard & do more trade deals & add more environmental restrictions we'll all be out of work. We gave the ranch away & what's worse we're still giving it away.
What it say is Mexico, Central and South America offer a better chance to fullfill your dreams.
They're immigrants, legal or not. They're not stupid. They know what is was like in their countries that encouraged them to try for a better life here. They believe this country is becoming more like what they left. The also believe that they, and all people of color, will become the scapegoats for all the ills that have befallen this nation. They're getting out while there's still time.
We shouldn't be surprised. Corporations have been doing it for years for the same reason.
Wow! The Congress and President Obama said they'd address the problem of illegal immigration and I guess they already have. Wonder how many jobs will be created when our feckless leaders decide to tear down that fence between the U.S. and Mexico?
Well. I guess they realized our government went down a bad path without a side road to pull over and re-think this whole situation, however maybe the very few available jobs there are will go to those actually born here, but when there is a crisis in Mexico I'm sure we will bale them out and add more to our debt, as if we are the only country everyone looks to for help. Well I guess the free food store is closed for now.
The Republicans are smarter than we thought, particularly the "tea baggers".
They have found a way to get the illegal immigrants out of the country.
They have made the economy and employment situation so bad in the US that illegal immigrants are returning to Mexico, where things are better.
A group was cutting through my yard yesterday and I begged them to take me with them. (They refused, of course.)
when the free lunch is gone time to leave so there is a up side to our debit problems
perry jones council bluffs ia
Another win for the Republicans !
It all adds up to a new illegal immigrant solution that is actually working
How many US companies now have business' located in Mexico, Jack? You know whats going on. Stop acting like you don't. And another thing the free-bees are running out?????
We need to build a wall to keep them in.
it means we need to give them all a free ride to the border.
Like rats deserting a sinking ship.
The US has become a third world country. Hmm, I speak a little Spanish. Maybe we should turn the tables on Mexico.
Gee Jack, maybe Obama and the Democrats should take credit for Mexico's economic growth. It's the least they could do, they haven't done anything to grow the US economy.
Being someone who makes less than 18,000 a year, I may need to get a passport after all.
It does not surprise me; on the cocntrary it actually sounds smart. Is it wrong for me to think that if we could bounce back from the great depression we can get out of this fiscal mess?
Genius on the part of Obama to eliminate the immigration problem.
I think it's great. The illegals are leaving voluntarily without taxpayers spending a dime. That leaves more jobs for Americans. It's good that Mexico is starting to do better, I am happy for them.
If we had known a recession would have that effect, we should have done it sooner
Now watch Mexico show us how to put a gate up.
I guess if you have to be broke and unemployed, you might as be broke and unemployed where its legal
every cloud has a silver lineing.
I say Great! No one should be here illegally anyways. Now that they are leaving, maybe our economy can start to grow again....
maybe the Mexican nationals can get jobs with their own Border Protection agency because it is increasingly likely Americans will be swimming across the Rio Grande in search of a better life
Is this what we needed to do to slow/stop illegal immigration, blow up our economy??
American dream, I am sorry but I am not familiar with those "terms". It's pretty sad when illegals leave your country because your country is THAT bad (not that having illegals is a good thing). Well guess that problem resolved its self out.
As for the American dream......oh yeah! that, it was sold in 1913 for a nice shiny new bank, you see people weren't using "the American dream" so they figure trade it in for counterfeit money, why not, I mean what could POSSIBLY go wrong? ™
Time to add Mexico to the list of retirement destinations. Friends of mine recently bought a place in Panama. According to them, their Social Security checks + retirement accounts buy more there than here.
Because here in America we have to wait for it to trickle down to us. Please Please give more tax cuts to the very wealthy because they are making our lives to rich and fulfilling.
It says it all.
West Chester PA
Who would have known that the "JOB CREATORS" could fix immigrations...Thanks GOP, now I can go back to work.
That doesnt make sense at all....it would make more sense if they were leaving for...for say China?
The reason Mexicans are going back to to their home country to work is because our American corporations are building plants and creating more jobs in Mexico than they are in the U.S. They have taken the U.S. production jobs to Mexico, China, India, Thailand. No reason for illegals to come here anymore. We are giving them jobs and paying them well to stay in their own country. It's works better than a fence to keep them out.
Illegals leaving? Aw, let me wave buy bye at the border!Good riddance!
Yeah, but ... the poverty rate in the US is around 21% and in Mexico it is over 43% so an employment rate in Mexico that is much lower than the US means what? Not much. The lower unemployment rate sounds like Mexico is doing better but doesn't really say much. Wait until we hit a poverty rate closer to Mexico's and then we can talk.
Thank god!!! I am glad they are going back. It looks like the bad economy does have a silver lining.
I suppose migrating back to Mexico, and economy increasing would cause an exodus. Afterall, all of the money they made here TAX FREE, most was sent back to their families. The economy can't help but to turn for the better. Maybe I will go to Mexico as an illegal and live on their economy. Hmmm...
Peopple are starting to clean their houses themselves.
Funny how people blame everyone except those responsible for our problem....it is not the Mexican or the lower tier of the economy that has caused our problem......it is the top who have abandoned our country......they have sent our jobs overseas. and moved their money to tax havens..... they have bought our politicians, and those politicians still command the loyalty of the masses, as being the folks who are going to create jobs.......the Mexicans are smarter than us.....
Well, what do you know... something good coming from the U. S. economic problems. The only long term solution to the illegal immigrants from Mexico is for the Mexican economy to provide enough jobs for the Mexican people. Strange that this should occur under these circumstances but I'll take good news where ever I can find it.
Sorry Jack. I don't believe a word of it. I lived in Mexico for 5 years and returned to the US last January because it was just too depressing. Somebody is lying with statistics. By the way, when I left, I was awed by the corruption and stupidity of the Mexican Government. Then we had the so called debt crisis here in the US. OK, I take it back. Looking at just the government, Mexico IS better.
I will tell you what it means. It means the Republicans once again are being controlled by an oligarchy which is duping their less – educated brethren into going against the President, the President who wants to protect Labor, who has already given incentives to small business to hire Americans. They are drinking Tea but Lord knows what it is spiked with – because all common sense is gone. What do these lower class and middle class Tea Partiers think will happen when there are no more funds to carry on the functions of government? When the bridges fall and the projects fail to get started because they have blocked them all? What do they think will happen to the airlines when they won't even pass the FAA Bill? Do they know the Tea Party plans to cut Medicare and weaken Labor every chance they get?
What kind of life are these people creating for themselves? The Koch brothers will be just fine but not the tea party folks.
Barbara Lou Townsend Palm Harbor, FL
I'm 28 years old and I have 2 young daughters. We started our family in 2008 after I was hired as a teacher. This past year, after I completed my master's degree, the school decided they didn't need me anymore. I'm currently looking for another job but things look bleak. I'll tell you I've honestly thought about jumping ship and looking for work in Canada. After hearing about Mexico, I'll add that to my list of places to emmigrate to
Jack-It means that things are so bad in America that we should send all the illegal aliens home and open up the estimated eight million American jobs currently held by these illegals.
It means that soon millions of American will be sneaking over the border into Mexico looking for work, and I am sure the Mexicans will welcome us, give our kids an education, and we can all press dos por Inglese.
It says that even illegal aliens can see what some Americans (republican voters) cannot; that American politicians don't care about anything other than wealthy people and big business, and that making a good middle-class living in the United States is just all talk....duhhhhh!
Maybe we can bring down our unemployment rate of 9.2 by getting jobs for our unemployed by working for FORD in Mexico,
I'll tell you what it means, Jack. It means our great Federal government has finally figured out a way to deal with our immigration problem; turn this country into so much of a joke nobody wants anything to do with it.
Central Americans and South Americans are Americans too. And don't forget that 1/3 of the U.S. was Mexico until we took it from them. It's good for North Americans if they can achieve the "American" dream. We lost an opportunity during the Bush years when he virtually ignored Central and South America. We still have an opportunity to improve relations with them.
What it says is that they found out that Obama has done them a favor, he shipped all the jobs to Mexico. Now they don't have to travel through that hot dessert in Arizona. They also found out that it's hotter in Texas than it is in Mexico.
At first I wondered why someone from another planet would go to Mexico. Then I realized you meant illegal immigrants not aliens. Shouldn't a US born citizen know definitions of commonly used words? Especially someone who is reporting news.
Mr. Obama, tear down that wall.
Your hate of poor Mexicans is appalling. You hate them because they come, you hate them because they leave. The truth is that Mexico is the 11th economy in the world these days, the truth is that for Mexico has ALWAYS BEEN A TRAGEDY to see their poor leave for the United States. The truth is that if they had hadthe opportunity there, and now they have it, they would have never come to the United States, where they have been mistreated, despised, and hated just because they wanted to improve their lives. It's about time Mexicans stay in their country to make it better. Mexican progress has been unheralded in the USA for decades, because it feels good when we think we are the best, now it is impossible to cover the sun with one finger.
If the unemployment rate is lower in Mexico, maybe we should cross the border to try to find employment there. It seems like no matter what we do to correct our debt problem, we are turning into a 3rd world nation.
Jack this country is in a downward spiral like never before. The disrespect our President. Congress not doing what their elected to do, the economy, FAA....Whats next? Talk about coming home to roost...Whats our future on the world stage?
It is unfortunate that you have so many "facts" wrong about Mexico, America and the undocumented worker. Bosses in America and in Mexico, including drug and political, are the ones always benefiting. The statistics and tone employed by your commentary seem to elaborate the lies perpetuated by those who benefit from worker infighting. The American and Mexican workers are losing wealth and purchasing power. All while the rich get richer and continue to exploit the rest. Please utilize more appropriate ways when speaking about an individual, "illegal" categorizes people as criminals. Also, it is caucasian whites who are flocking to Mexico.
Things here must be worse than I had thought if Mexicans are returning to a land torn apart by drug violence. It's bad here, but I would think it would be better than the constant daily threat imposed upon people by the cartels. Not to mention their government is more corrupt than ours! What is this world coming to.
Good for Mexico! Maybe we should send some of our esteemed politicians down there to get a few lessons in restoring an economy and a country. Sure might be a good use of their time and our money. Beats doing nothing!
St. Louis, MO
Mexico should build a big wall with a moat full of crocodiles, to keep us Americans out.
I can see why the Mexicans are going back home, we have a Congress that is "Anti American" and corrupt.
They went home for a month of boozing and broads without doing a thing.They cut everything that their masters tell them to cut.
What about the IOU's to Social Security, why does no one mention this?
We need term limits of two terms. Theys hould not be allowed to give themselves raises and should NOT get benefits for life. They need a merit system.
They should all be voted out of office and a fresh start made and if that does work recall the non-producers.
They are probably getting better economy because some American businesses have built plants in Mexico for cheaper help!
Your comments about illegal aliens returning to Mexico due to lack of jobs made me chuckle to myself, and not in a good way. As much as I love this country, I'm out of work, out of unemployment, running out of money, have nearly two Masters degrees under my belt, can't find a job and am thinking of moving out of the country, to Israel. At least I'd get some help finding a job and be able to work.
The GOP finally found a way to remove the illegal immigrants back to their home country at no cost to the USA!!! I am surprised the Republicans have not boasted that they have saved Americans millions of dollars and now have a well deserved vacation even though many Americans will not receive paychecks for the next 5 weeks. What a cheerful and nice Party!
That is the best news ive heard in along time jack!!! Republicans are going to take back our country from obama and the liberals!!! If i could i would help them pack!!!
Look, I just left South America. Forget what games the Federal gov't might have regarding Americans looking abroad for work. There needs to be a discussion about Americans having the balls to look for work abroad regardless if that means less revenue for the Feds. Eike Batista in Brazil is hiring American welders, believe it not. Working class Americans working abroad, the new norm! IRS beware!
Comes as no surprise to me, tax-exempt Corporate profit-hoarders and their Congressional lackeys moved all the jobs to Mexico, I'd go too, if they'd have me!
These are good news! Particularly for you Jack, maybe now you can get a new job in Mexico. But come to think of it, maybe the Mexicans won’t want you there either.
It says that the millionaire and billionaires are too busy closing down our factories and opening in other countries where they get cheap labor and tax shelters. These are the companies that American workers built. It says that these free trade agreements are anything but free for Americans. We need Fair trade and tariffs and not free trade, and we need to fire Congress.
Republicans, or Tea Partiers, or whatever they are called now, must be just wetting themselves with joy over their rapid destruction of the once great United States.
Hey Jack, Maybe this is all part of the plan. The crappy economy must be Obama's covert immigration policy. He's smarter than we thought. Love ya, love your show.
Maybe now the free things they got are all gone. the free ride is over
ed in ny
The illegals are returning to Mexico to take the jobs that have been moved to Mexico from the United States. Bring the jobs back here and see the trend reverse again.
It just proves how rotten Obama's policies have been! And the he does NOT deserve another 4 more years! He has this country on the WRONG path, as evidence illegal aliens fleeing the country for a better opportunity in Mexico.
There a bright side to every situation. Their goes the Republican party cheap labor ,and the Democratic party furture voteing block.The illegals will get the same jobs because the American companys have moved to Mexico.
Corporate America sent all of our jobs to China. Which means nothing for Mexicans, either. USA is doomed.
The emigration of mexican 'aliens' from the US means that as usual America is spending its energies, fighting the wrong war with the wrong people at the wrong time and for the wrong reasons.
Not only mexicans, at least 4 in 10 brazilians have return home here in SW Florida. We used to have 43 brazilian churchers here, some with over 300 hundred members, and today there is about 8 left and none of them have more then 60 members.
it might mean i can finally get a job
This is the silver lining to the economic cloud we are currently experiencing. I wish them well and may they prosper. Also, maybe there will be more help now for the people who are entitled to it.
Yea, I worked with lot of Mexicans back on 9/11 and lots of employes wanted to leave because it wasn't safe here anymore. now the economey is driveing them away. I guess if you don't have roots it's ease to move. I hope the Mexicans treat us better that we treated them as we become the lawless land of despair and willing to swim the Rio Grand! Thanks Congress, you guys did a good job on Imagration!
Well Jack your country is in real trouble now.. Who is going to pick the fruit & Vegitables ,manicure the lawns & train your dogs. Americans aren't goiung to do that work. Even if they are unemployed
Jack, Mexico's success is simply a byproduct of its plummeting birthrate. In short, there are fewer and fewer Mexicans. Mexico has also had a spell of relatively good leadership during the last decade. We should be overjoyed that our southern neighbor is no longer a banana republic, which is exactly where we're headed if we keep on electing more tea party morons.
We're sending them back home with a better defined outline on how to do their work with skill and armed with social skills, it can only go in the right direction. Maybe we schooled them so well it's benefiting their own country now.
I've been using an audio course to teach myself Spanish. I thought I was adding to my skills for working in the US. I didn't realize that I was preparing for a future career in Mexico.
It means that our government in its infinate ignorance has fallen behind 3rd world countries in its ability to effectively legislate a solvent ecomomy. They have far too much interest in creating perks for themselves and representing the partys rather than the people. I say let's throw all the bums out and elect a congress of third year high school students. They seem infinately smarter tham those in Washington at this time.
This is one good thing to come out of the decline of the U.S.; as illegal aliens leave our country it just might eliminate the spectacle of watching our fearless leaders engage in verbal combat over yet another issue they can't deal with...immigration reform.
It was bound to happen Jack. The danger from Drug Cartels is much less than the danger From MAD DOG Tea Party Members. These people are intelligent and have an Option. If I had an Option I'd take it to. This is no longer the USA I signed up to Protect and defend in the 1972.
Pretty soon we'll have out-of-work Americans sneaking into Mexico looking for work. Maybe we can get Mexico to build the fence.
Jack it says the idiot in the White House needs to stop giving Mexico our money and to make Mexico start paying the U.S. money for harboring it's citizens .
It means American companies that will be moving their businesses to Mexico won't need to check the legal status of it's employees, they will all be legal.
Gee Jack, there is no mystery here. Illegals have for years been paid "under the table" in cash...paying no taxes and getting their medical care, etc. for free...even though they're illegals. Many have lived in squalor, sending half their "cash" to relatives, making their lives easier. This has been going on forever...ever since I was a kid growing up in CA. Now, all the American cash has shored up the Mexican economy. As US jobs decline and big business continue to "off shore" their businesses and not pay any taxes or are subsidized by our government e.g. Ag. it's more attractive to "go home". I guess that's one way to enforce our immigration laws.
They came. They lived off American tax payers. They took our jobs. Now they're leaving us to clean up the mess. Thanks a lot!
Good, Maybe things will pick up in America. They come over here illegal barely know how to speak the English language if they speak it. Getting all the assistance as well as over populate.
I think it means that Mexicans are more in touch with the "now" in America than most Americans. They are very adaptable people and they are not afraid to start over again, when it makes sense to do that.
That's an easy one Jack. It means chicken breasts at 8 dollars a pound, lettuce at 10 dollars a head, if you can find it. Fruit and vegetable farmers losing hundreds of thousands of dollars in ruined crops and restaurants closing for lack of kitchen staff. Yup, the good 'ole boys have manged to run off the illegals, bankrupt farmers, restaurants, and construction firms while doubling the cost of my food bill.
US has collapsed and it's now at at point of no return. Very soon most citizens will be moving to Mexico to settle and this includes the like of President Bush and Obama and all the house and congress members.
Austella vista baby
Jack, why do you call the people that are in our country illegally "aliens"? Most of these "immigrants" are not from outer space.
with major companies like gm tripping over theiir own feet in a race to ship as many jobs as they can out of our countries its no wonder mexicans want to head home.
Regarding your report, 'Illegal aliens leaving U.S., returning to Mexico for better life?'
I was surprised to learn that every illegal alien is assumed to be Mexican, are there any illegal aliens heading back to Ireland, England, Canada or Poland? I happen to personally know there are European illegals here in the US, many are my friends.
Not sure how this data is amassed but surely not every illegal alien is from Mexico. I believe it is dangerous when the term illegal alien is synonymous with Mexico, kind of like Gillette and razor blades.
Henry from Bayonne
NAFTA is working. This shows that the standard of living is lowering in America so other countries are equal to ours.
This gives me a feeling that the notion of "American Dream" is not too far from over.
Maybe the Mexican goverment can give us some advice on how to grow
It means that there is a positive side to the countries economic troubles.
Tucson, AZ – This means that the United 'States Congress continues to make a botch of the US economy. Make no mistake – the House and its Speaker, not the President, have Constitutional control of , and authority over, ALL domestic taxing, borrowing, and spending, so there is no sense pointing at the White House for things House and Senate Republicans have done Who would have guessed that the Republicans would solve the illegal immigration problem by causing a depression? Where did these guys learn economics, from comic books? This Congress was elected to create jobs and has done nothing to create them but has caused the loss of many others. Are they kidding, or just stupid?
While the Mexicans may be leaving the USA, in my town foreigners still come here by the droves to work on the yachts of the very wealthy Americans. Yes, you guessed it, these yachts are crewed in a great majority by foreigners from all over the world and at very good wages. Less than 5% of crew onboard these yachts are American citizens so you guessed it again, these wealthy US yacht owners have very few US citizens as their crew working for them on their luxury yachts. Why? Because the loop holes in our maritime regulatory system and Customs & Border Protection permit the wealthy owners to flag their yachts in foreign corporations allowing them to hire anyone they choose. In addition quite often these crew are from countries who have national health so the yacht owners do not have to provide health insurance for their crew either. I would place a bet that these yacht owners are probably either republican or tea party voters. There is definitely something wrong with this picture…..
Does this mean Farm Jobs are now available?????
I am originally from the UK, I came to the US, in 2004 legally,
I have news for you.... it is just not Mexicans leaving the USA, I have friends from all over the world who live in the USA, and a good 20% of them are leaving and heading home., and I am one of them.
History is repeating its self Jack, All great nations eventually fail, It happened to the Egyptians The Greeks, Romans, and in more recent times, the British Empire, and USSR. It is now America's turn
Within the next 10 -20 years, the USA will be unrecognizable.
Funny i am just wondering how Mexico will deal with illegal immigrants that are United States citizens in the years to come.
It says that its time to finally do something about underwater mortgages besides facilitating foreclosure. It also says we are undertaxed, allowing CEOs to profit too much from lowering wages and trimming staff.
Yea! I think that is one solution to the our debt problem! If you are illegally in the country then you should have NO rights and should go back to your own country. The fact that they are volunarily going home is a plus for lowering all the entitlements going to illegals. If you are illegal that means you are not paying taxes, SS, health premiums, etc.. I for one say great!
geez, Maybe Mexico will float us a loan? Can I just get in line down their for a job, maybe some where near the beach.
America, we're # __________
Are you kidding me, do you really think America cares if immigrants go back to their country thrive after they have been in America for years making good money sending it back to Mexico all while they lived tax free? I know that is a run on sentence but how could I shorten it with so many facts? Please America, we are intelligent enough surely to see this.
If everyone in America would just mow their own lawn, then more illegals will be going back to Mexico.
Says our states should secede from our government cause are government is destroying us. Seceding would give us a chance to survive!
Mexico is in better shape than U.S.
Understandable! U.S. companies are outsourcing jobs and industries to China and India. There are more American jobs available in China and India than in America. It used to be a privilege to come to the U.S. but now it's just an option. I think it is pretty clear now that outsourcing is killing the US. Government officials need to end this tragic practice. The only way to rebuild the economy is with JOBS yet more jobs are being sent abroad. Greedy US CEOs will continue to outsource the U.S. to death if left unchecked. The "as long as I am getting rich" mentality of US CEOs who support outsourcing is the poison that is slowly killing this nation. What a shame!
that is all great and wonderful, but can we make sure they return the free cell phone that our wonderful democratic government gave them as well as the food stamp cards they got from our wonderful democratic government.
For 2 1/2 years, I was in disbelief that Americans would vote for an inexperienced, know little, do less person for president. Now he proves us all wrong by purposely, single-handedly destroying America just to get rid of all the illegal immigrants that his party has coveted to get the Hispanic vote. I am really glad to see that he has finally achieved something benficial for the American people. Maybe, soon, he will be able to get us some foreign aid from such a wonderful country in which to live. (or die)
It just shows how the Wall Street capitalist elite have turned the United States into a third world nation.
This is AMAZING to consider.... I'm almost speechless. Our immigration problem could solve itself at this rate. It's sad that our nation is willing to forfeit it's legacy in the international society for this new elitist, separatist, super right wing idealism that IS NOT the essence of AMERICA! We have become a nation of Cannibals in every possible way. I wish the illegal aliens well!
No comment needed!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Jack, it says that if something isn't done about the continuous slide in the earning power of the middle class, then revenue will continue to also slide, even as the number of the needy and their needs rise. The war on the middle class must end, or eventually all the spending cuts in the world won't be enough. Our middle class was once the envy of the world, and it has been picked apart by every means imaginable, in order to redistribute more of the wealth to the top few. 80% of all the growth in income over the last 30 years has gone to the top 1%. If that keeps up, we have neo-feudalism, not a democracy, and the post mortem on this country will closely parallel the fable about the goose who laid the golden eggs. We should demand Economic Patriotism in DC, starting with the abrogation of NAFTA, and moving on from there. It shouldn't be too much to ask."
looks like something wrong with our system – countries with a big government, like Mexico, China, Russia, are doing better...
Not only are the Mexicans returning to Mexico, but tens of thousands of US citizens are coming to Mexico to retire because we simply cannot afford to do so in the US. Here we have cheap fresh food and prescription drugs, beautiful housing with low property taxes, excellent services, and affordable medical care. Will your doctor make a chouse call in the middle of the night for $35? And in most of the country, the cartels are not a significant issue. Come on down, the weather is fantastic!
Is Congress spending their 5 weeks off in Mexico to learn how to turn an economy around? Do they have Republicans in Mexico. Maybe that's the secret.
Mexican workers were often migrants that crossed back and forth across the border. As the seasonal crops and labor contracts came in, so did the Mexicans. It's good that they have a place that they can go back to that provides healthcare, housing, education and other benefits. Todays politicians in the U.S. regard such things as entitlements with little esteem. I don't want to stay here either.
This country is going down fast. If I had the money I would leave this country my self.
After listening to the news, I am sick to my stomach. Our Congress went on a 5 week vacation and left business hanging. What kind of people run this country? And illegal aliens returning to Mexico! Maybe the illegals will run into our Congressmen & women on vacation in Mexico and they can tell them to return home and finish their job. Can we fire Congress and start over again with non-political people. I bet the average American could do a better job running this country. Mexico is doing well because we sent them so many of our jobs-it's past time to repatriate these jobs, tax the the rich (they only create jobs in other countries), and close the tax loop holes. Poor President Obama can't get anything done because the Congress puts a wall up every time he tries to do something. Kinda makes me think that Congress wants to see the downfall of the greatest nation on earth. Remember this on election day'
There is no such thing as the American Dream. People all over the world are just trying their best to have a good life for themselves and their families. We need to start thinking globally and not nationally. My experience with Americans is that they can't think that way. It's all about them. Now look at the mess you're in.
Learn to speak, read, and write Spanish.
Obama has done a great job regarding addressing our immigration problem, as now even the illegals want to leave our country, SO WHAT ABOUT OUT THE REST OF US? Do we then have to stay here...
Why would any illegal stay here, when those of us who are citizens feel as if they are no longer being represented by our elected legislators? I am so disgusted and disappointed by our members of Congress who seem to be fixated on the money they can collect from lobbyists and special interest groups that "we, the people" are hardly worth a second glance. How about them giving up a 5 week loss of income like the FAA workers? How about our Congressmen giving up not only some of their pay, but also have to work a real 5-day week, weekends if necessary with perhaps a 2 week vacation yearly, but also be required to have exactly the same medical insurance, pension and retirement benefits (and loss of franking privileges) that the rest of us have to look forward to? It's time they learned how the majority of the people live.
How can I hitch a ride there and where do I look for an apartment that takes pets?
Jack, I so don't feel badly over people leaving CA. I live here in CA and as far as I have always believed, it might be about time that unless you have lived here in America correctly then get the heck out! I have had friends who have moved to other countries to live and they have time limits before they can work, get Gov help, and many other things, we should be doing that. New Zealand for example has a 1yr living as a resident, before anything can happen. WE have the Statue of Liberty,but I think that again LET's TAKE CARE OF AMERICAN's before helping others
Well, Jack, what do you know? We actually have one of our major economic headaches showing improvement without any drama from Washington.
All levity aside, I truly understand our bleak U.S. economic situation that has brought this about.......but I have been desperately poor for many years, and didn't harbor some of the nasty attitudes that our nation of immigrants has had against these poor folks who came here to find a better life...........not all Mexican immigrants are drug runners...........as our Border Patrols have demonstrated so aptly over the last few weeks.
Looks like all those politicians who planned use deportation of illegal aliens as a campaign platform will have to find another group of folks to attack that can't fight back..........hmmm, could it be those of us on disability? ANYtHING to avoid talking about the economy...
It means we did a great job building Mexico's economy. Mexico exported it's poor and uneducated to Mexico for generations and gave them information on how to work the system. In addition, it was and is a great source of revenue for Mexico. Several years ago I heard that it was somewhere around the 3 largest source – just below oil. More recently, I have heard that it is about 18th. Who knew that exporting your poor could be such a good source of revenue for a country. To the credit of Hispanic workers, they're hard workers which is one of the reasons that U.S. employers prefer them. They show up and work hard. You've seen a great many of them on stimulus funded road projects which means a lot of the stimulus money went to Mexico.
Many Hispanics do not even know that what they are doing is wrong; they think it's the way things are done in the U.S. because that's what they've been told. One very fine gentleman I know was given an insurance allotment through work which he didn't use. When asked about why he hadn't used it, he said that the government pays for his and his family's medical bills – probably at hospital emergency rooms. This is a great guy and never even considered that what he was doing was wrong.
dear Jack, the mexicans have came here & made pleanty of cash money& returned to mexico. If the I>N>S> ever wants to catch them visit any paint store in the U.S. Jim
Jack, I am not an expert and so I am young, however I am afraid that the united States is riding the same train that led to end of the old Soviet Union. Should I say the explosion of Capitalism?
That would sound like a Supernova.
Raymond from Kansas City
So what Americans are going to start taking their jobs.......cutting
lawns, low wage retail, low wage restaurants, farm work, etc......?
I guess the republicans and tea party got what they wanted–illegals out of THEIR country. All they had to do was simply bring the US economy to the brink of diaster-with an unessary war -Iraq and not agreeing to raise the debt ceiling.
Let those illegals go do that back-breaking work in their own country. Americans certainly want to work in the agricultural fields for min wage
Jack. I suppose the republicans will take credit for the lack of jobs in America as reason for the illegals going south too. They want all the credit for what is going right, but none of the responsibility for what they have run in the ditch. They continue to harp on the 35% tax rate on big business, when in fact last year I paid more in taxes that did Exxon. With all the loopholes the republicans keep for their big business friends, any American that paid a nickle in after decutions tax paid more than most all if not all big business. Why did not all the tax breaks for the rich & powerfull not create jobs during the last administration, instead or our losing 600,000+ jobs per month? What the republicans are doing may not be illegal, but it surely is immoral!
Please, God, let it mean that Glenn Beck will shut his mouth.
Should have read my post closer. I meant that Mexico exported its poor to the United States.
very good question jack. we are a asian family living here for the past 7 years, But now we are getting the feeling is life would be much better off in our country than here. The answer to your question is this country is not leading in a good direction that makes everybody think to be here or fled to where they came from.
The first thing it tells me is the cartels are winning. With so many American Dollars and [tax payer provided] guns going towards their drug enterprises, it only seems logical that they will keep winning. Even with a tightened border they keep a foothold on our shores with Mexicans growing pot in our own parks; but the money still goes South.
i think mexico and canada should start building a wall
I would like to be an immigrant in another country. After they drain all the states, its time to go back. Don't let the door hit you on the way out!!!
They might as well, Ford, Gm, Chrysler have moves all the good paying U.S. jobs down there!!! Greedy MFG in the U.S are moving jobs to Mexico faster than the Mexicans are moving to the U.S.
Funny part of it all, built in Mexico, sold in U.S., profit goes offshore not to ever be taxed! Why do we continue to give tax breaks to them???
We still have all the service jobs here but untill we once again become a producing nation rather than a comsumer and service nation we will NEVER see enough good paying jobs to sustain our economy!!!
I suspect that we will be exporting our wealthy to Mexico and other countries. What insane policy import massive numbers of poor and export your wealthy. What country would not welcome a small number of wealthy people?
I can imagine a time when the Mexican's have to increase their border patrol to keep the Americans out. Remember the show, "The American
Century", well it's over.
That news is little comfort to the 14-22 million legal immigrants and citizens who can't find a job and/or lose their home because Obama is playing poitics instead getting them back to work!!
Republicans planned it that way. Any more room on the bus?
Good riddance. What other country in the world lets people just wander in, stay, and receive a plethora of welfare and benfits? Rather than doing anything to enforce our illegal immigration laws, the Keystone Cops in this administration are doing all they can to stop the states from enforcing our laws. If this administration gets another four years, we all will be headed for Mexico.
We need to put more Tea Partiers in Office and then we can all go to Mexico!
Here in SW Florida not only mexicans are leaving but at least 4 in 10 Brazil natives have left since 2009,at one point there was over 43 brazilian churches some with over 300 members and today there is about 8 churches left and the bigger one with no more than 60 members. Brazilian Restaurants and bakeries are now part of history. I think that the number of 12 million illegal immigrants have now drop to no more than 9 million.
That's a good thing jack. They came here to steal jobs and everything else they could get away with. I'm so sick of hearing these people do the jobs Americans won't do, that's hogwash! Those people are desperate and they see the Americans are getting as desperate as they are. American will be doing the jobs they do and sthey see it coming.
If Mexico's economy is doing great,well good. All thanks to NAFTA.
Do you think the Mexican government will allow Americans to be illegal aliens in Mexico? Hell No Jack!
It's always greener on the other side of the Rio Grande.
What does it say that illegal aliens are leaving the U.S. and returning to Mexico in search of a better life?
Jack it says that companies are hiring Americans not leaving any jobs for illegals.
Oh no! Who is gonna cut my grass now? It's Bush's falt. Wait ..maybe it's the Tea Parties. Actually they are just going home while things are slow here in the USA. They will get the wife pregnant and be back as soon as things pick up. Besides they left the oldest kid here so they won't miss collage classes and make sure all the little ones go to school and get their free lunch, deposit the welfare check and collect the food stamps, and make sure they won't lose ther subsidized housing.
Jack Cafferty sounds off hourly on the Situation Room on the stories crossing his radar. Now, you can check in with Jack online to see what he's thinking and weigh in with your own comments online and on TV.
About Jack Cafferty
Subscribe | Send Feedback